Manager out. Vote

Should we sack silva

  • Yes

    Votes: 374 33.3%

  • No

    Votes: 499 44.5%

  • I’m a fence sitting kenwright lover

    Votes: 62 5.5%

  • Didn’t want him in the first place

    Votes: 187 16.7%
  • Total voters
    1,122
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Barnfred 55 said:
Not sure whether anybody else is as confused as I am at the moment. I feel like Sméagol from Lord of the Rings.

The sensible me understands that we need a period of consolidation. That the manager and DoF need time to put their own team/squad together, and allow new players games to get accustomed to the premier league. That we have the nucleus of a decent squad and 3/4 quality additions (plus 15 or so departures) will see us competing at the top level. That up until 7 weeks ago we were, on the whole, very happy with the direction the team and club were taking. That the very last thing we need at the moment is even more disruption, starting over again with new manager and players etc. That realistically, the conditions last night played right into the hands of a shock result, and losing away in the cup to a side from a division below is not that unusual anyway and possibly happens 40/50% of the time.

Then this voice in the back of my head pops up and tells me in no uncertain terms that I'm in denial. That Silva is a clueless coach who has lost the players. That we've been there before with Martinez and the longer he stays the worse it gets.

I really don't know what I want for the best. What I do know is that it's horrible being a blue at the moment and it's eating me from the inside.
Click to expand...
Im edgeing toward your 2nd option
 

GETEM said:
We’re 5 games into the 2nd half of the season, the teams around us will probably all have to play the same teams
Click to expand...

Oh I agree totally, however our home games are against the top 5 and we don’t win away, so it’s dofficult to see what’s the points come from for a top 7 finish.

I’m not saying we end up in a relegation scrap but bottom half finish is easily possible. Should he be kept on based on that and 2 terrible cup runs?
 

hktoffee said:
7th is a bit better than average. EL footie afterall.

The gap between 6th and the rest is massive.
Click to expand...

Thats still not an answer

7th for me is average. We disagree. Fine. But you didn't answer the original question.

It's easy to say sack but what is your idea for how to run things going forward. Sack every new manager when they have a crap start?

You say get a proven manager. How long do you give them if they start crap also?

It's easy to say sack. And that less than 7th is not good enough. And that long-term thinking means nothing. And that a crap home record is not good enough.

But are you saying you want a new manager every season if they cannot give you that? Because all I hear are demands HK.
 
bicycleheader said:
Thats still not an answer

7th for me is average. We disagree. Fine. But you didn't answer the original question.

It's easy to say sack but what is your idea for how to run things going forward. Sack every new manager when they have a crap start?

You say get a proven manager. How long do you give them if they start crap also?

It's easy to say sack. And that less than 7th is not good enough. And that long-term thinking means nothing. And that a crap home record is not good enough.

But are you saying you want a new manager every season if they cannot give you that? Because all I hear are demands HK.
Click to expand...

I have answered you pal. The minimum requirement is 7th in the league. This is a fair assessment given the squad we have and the money we have spent. The gap is massive between top 6 and the rest but to accept anything lower than 7th? Really? No wonder some people deserve 11th and will feel fine.

What can you see that we are going forward? There’s no evidence. Results are getting worse than last season. We are getting beaten by crap at home and fail to beat some dross teams at home. It’s an embarrassment to concede so much through setpieces.

There is a highly tenancy for these top proven manager to succeed because their past records had proven so. To get low tiar manager and hoping he does a Klopp is like throwing a daze.

A good manager can get the best out of his his squad and stay competitive with little budget. Look at what Moyes had done.
 
hktoffee said:
I have answered you pal. The minimum requirement is 7th in the league. This is a fair assessment given the squad we have and the money we have spent. The gap is massive between top 6 and the rest but to accept anything lower than 7th? Really? No wonder some people deserve 11th and will feel fine.

What can you see that we are going forward? There’s no evidence. Results are getting worse than last season. We are getting beaten by crap at home and fail to beat some dross teams at home. It’s an embarrassment to concede so much through setpieces.

There is a highly tenancy for these top proven manager to succeed because their past records had proven so. To get low tiar manager and hoping he does a Klopp is like throwing a daze.

A good manager can get the best out of his his squad and stay competitive with little budget. Look at what Moyes had done.
Click to expand...

i dont think you understood that i was asking you a question. or understood any of my posts.

none of the replies have answered what i was asking.
 

degsy said:
Some, players and managers, do it better than others...we need one of the better ones
Click to expand...
Yes, be nice to get some with a bit of pride. They bottled it yesterday to a pub team. What a complete shower of cowards. Wish you could really swear on this site because nothing else in the language is sufficient. Gomez will come good again when it is not as chilly, DCL likewise when the rain stops and it is not so muddy, he has a female fan base and has to look his posing best, several good balls into the box and where was he? Looking in to his vanity mirror. Richarlison was playing with a ladder in his tights so going through the pain barrier. Digne showed that despite his ability he could make Ross seem like a University Challenge contestant. How dumb have you got to be? You have only got to look at Pickford to know there is something not quite all there. Lookman...one way to Germany please. i could go on and probably will later. What a scumbag shower of excuses for men that lot are.
 
wiggum23 said:
Oh I agree totally, however our home games are against the top 5 and we don’t win away, so it’s dofficult to see what’s the points come from for a top 7 finish.

I’m not saying we end up in a relegation scrap but bottom half finish is easily possible. Should he be kept on based on that and 2 terrible cup runs?
Click to expand...

I’d say keep him but i wouldn’t be too upset if he went.
 
I think something is so wrong, deep within the club, that not even Guardiola could get a consistent tune out of our players.

Pointless changing the manager until we work out what is wrong within the club and get it fixed. That would be treating the symptoms and not the cause.

The problem is, nobody (myself included) seems to know what the root cause of our problems is!
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top