This is the way I see it.
I think he's a clever player with a good football brain and good ability.
However, I want Everton to be the best, or at least kick on to the next level.
I believe we have the manager to do so, and we have some players to do so. We possibly need a few more better players.
I don't think Leon Osman is good enough to be in a team at that next level, or even enough of a personality to be a match winner and win anything with us.
Bringing him on late in games could be an option where he will have the legs to make an impact but he simply can't for 90, he gives the ball away too cheaply and too often to be in a team so reliant on possession.
I'd love him to prove me wrong and win some silverware at the club but he just doesn't strike me as a winner.