2024/25 Kevin Thelwell

Status
Not open for further replies.

I love it when people say this about Thelwell…

All good signings? then why are we still absolutely garbage eh.

His loan signings have been beyond garbage. Best 2 he's had so far is Mangala and Coady who played a lot the season he was here so I'd say that was a useful loan

We've had

Vinagre - garbage
Harrison - garbage
Danjuma - obvious manager didn't want him and garbage
Broja - injured
Lindstrom - jury still out until he has a consistent run under Moyes

I've probably missed out more as well, signing wise the jury is out on Chermiti, Beto we can all see what he is, Mcneil I'd hope we might recoup what we paid for him, Garner has missed 23 games in 3 seasons which is a lot. Onana we turned a profit on but we paid a heck of a lot of money on him when the priority should have been on a quality front man.

Glad that O'Brien is starting to get minutes, but again that now definitely looks like a signing that the manager didn't want and dug his heels in by not playing him.
 
Pity we never had fit players in key positions then one keeper on the bench h is adequate IMO..
Not debating that mate but if one of your keepers gets injured you’re down to two, as opposed to having one keeper.

Imagine Pickford got injured whilst Virginia was as well? U21 keeper or 18s? No thanks.
 
Not sure just how much he’s actually involved this window but it’s certainly changing my perception of him. To have the entire month and wait until there’s a week of the window left is looking pretty negligent right now.
 

Not sure just how much he’s actually involved this window but it’s certainly changing my perception of him. To have the entire month and wait until there’s a week of the window left is looking pretty negligent right now.

…he left us 7 games into a season with no striker when he first came and then bought Maupay. Needless to say we struggled for a central striker all season with DCL injured lots.
 

Marcel Brands was infinitely worse as a DOF than Thelwell
And Steve Walsh was infinitely worse than him, yet neither get constant weird abuse about their appearance on here. I know I’m being soft cus it’s banter but does my head in that

That being said, if he can’t bring in a couple this window I’d probably move on from him in the summer. It’s been obvious since September what positions we desperately needed bodies in for
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top