“Up there with the best ever that”
You're all up in Pickles' thread today...
“Up there with the best ever that”
How can you not love him, the absolute nutterYou're all up in Pickles' thread today...![]()

Anybody around 40 and below it must surely be:100%, older posters may have their own opinions but for me, my order goes
Nev
JP
Nigel Martyn
Tim Howard
Southall isn't the greatest because he was in a winning team. We had a winning team because it had Neville Southall. A genius.Anybody around 40 and below it must surely be:
Pickford
Martyn
Howard
Southall (simply because he was miles past his best in the 90s and that's our goal memory of him)
Obviously Everton GOAT in goal is Neville, especially since he was part of a highly successful team, whereas Pickford hasn't able to celebrate any success with us.
How can you not love him, the absolute nutter
I’d be amazed if he hasn’t just earned himself another save of the month award![]()
Yes no doubt.is he the best ever Everton keeper after Southall?
Obviously Everton GOAT in goal is Neville, especially since he was part of a highly successful team, whereas Pickford hasn't able to celebrate any success with us.
Just came on here to say that I think he is. The last decade hasn’t been great for Evertonians, but having Pickford as a toffee has been a highlight.is he the best ever Everton keeper after Southall?
Join the Everton conversation today.
Fewer ads, full access, completely free.