Can I ask what is this old da bit ,I am 76 and that has no effect on my judgement of players .The only thing is I have seen great Everton teams ,so can tell the difference in those who are good enough and those stealing a living . To compare Stevie P with him or Harrison is misjudged ,some thing has blurred with time for you .
Not blurred at all mate, I remember how Pienaar was looked at after he arrived and same stuff said about Lindstrom was said about him, can't hack it in this league, too weak etc etc etc.
He was said to be too weak for the league and his game suited Spain more, his big money move to Dortmund flopped on part to them having a weirdly similar situation to Napoli last year, three managers, a horrid season and Pienaar getting a lot of the blame as a big money flop.
Funny thing though I also am.old enough to remember Ratcliffe getting dogs abuse from the crowd for being crap initially.
As fans we historically have loved to jump on a player early on and write them off, despite it time and again showing we maybe we should wait before writing off a player who joined a few months this earlier - and Lindstrom has being getting slated by some now since September.
Nothings blurred with time for me but do think you look back and your judgement is based on how they ended up being rather than your initial knee jerk reaction, ofc you may have from day one thought Ratcliffe was amazing or Jags looked a great buy as he failed around looking clueless in centre mid, or Coleman looked like he'd become a great right back as he played on the wing, or that indeed Pienaar looked physically up for the league in his first few months. Still remember this place when
Branthwaite started and got sent off, yeah lots were saying the lads gonna be worth 70+ million, nobody kinda reacted like he was crap.