2025/26 James Tarkowski



People are sheep for stating he's not been very good this season? In my opinion, Tarkowski doesn’t look nearly as solid when Branthwaite isn’t alongside him, and that’s been true not just this season.
I can see your point, its just that once criticism of a certain player starts on here I feel that so many just follow.
Nothing personal to anyone, I've posted loads of sheep before on other threads - just a bit of a joke really.
Oh, & he's my favourite so I'm a bit sensitive when he's criticised 😊
 
I can see your point, its just that once criticism of a certain player starts on here I feel that so many just follow.
Nothing personal to anyone, I've posted loads of sheep before on other threads - just a bit of a joke really.
Oh, & he's my favourite so I'm a bit sensitive when he's criticised 😊
I think he’s a bit of a yard dog, to be honest. It’s surprising that Keane is performing better, especially given how out of favour he was. Overall, the defence hasn’t been performing well, and the captain who was very very solid last season has to take some responsibility for that. The midfield getting overrun is also a major issue and not helping us defensively.

 

The only thing with Tarkowski is that because he plays so tough and old school, he’s well-known by the refs. I feel any time he challenges, it’s a 50/50 chance of getting booked just because of his reputation.
 

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top