James McCarthy

Status
Not open for further replies.


Besic, Cleverly, Gibson and even change into a 1 CM role would work better then having him there.

Offers nothing

Agreed. The best two central midfielders in the squad in my opinion are Besic and Barkley (Gibson would be in there if he could stay fit). Gibson and Cleverley are good cover in each position. McCarthy was overpriced in my opinion and not good enough to command the guaranteed starter spot he always has ahead of Besic.

Ideally we go out in the summer and get a manager who can teach Barkley how to play in a central two, and can attract a top creative midfielder either at number 10 or as a deep lying conductor who can dictate play.
 
Besic, Cleverly, Gibson and even change into a 1 CM role would work better then having him there.

Offers nothing
It's absolute madness that we play with two DM at almost every conceivable point in the last 3 seasons. Even when things weren't really going that well, still have 2 players in that role.
 
Hasn't been in form recently, but I honestly think that pound for pound he is our best overall player

People are very quick to forget just how good he's been for us since we signed him

I'm loving some of the Gibson shouts as well. He was dirt to most of you a few weeks ago and now all of a sudden he's the savior of our season and a bonafide CM maestro?

State of some of you. You'll turn on a sixpence with nary a second of thought
 

Hasn't been in form recently, but I honestly think that pound for pound he is our best overall player

People are very quick to forget just how good he's been for us since we signed him

I'm loving some of the Gibson shouts as well. He was dirt to most of you a few weeks ago and now all of a sudden he's the savior of our season and a bonafide CM maestro?

State of some of you. You'll turn on a sixpence with nary a second of thought
here here...joke
 
Hasn't been in form recently, but I honestly think that pound for pound he is our best overall player

People are very quick to forget just how good he's been for us since we signed him

I'm loving some of the Gibson shouts as well. He was dirt to most of you a few weeks ago and now all of a sudden he's the savior of our season and a bonafide CM maestro?

State of some of you. You'll turn on a sixpence with nary a second of thought

Players are just robots to some. There isn't such thing as being in or out of form, they are either good or bad players.

Can't understand it, myself.
 
Hasn't been in form recently, but I honestly think that pound for pound he is our best overall player

People are very quick to forget just how good he's been for us since we signed him

I'm loving some of the Gibson shouts as well. He was dirt to most of you a few weeks ago and now all of a sudden he's the savior of our season and a bonafide CM maestro?

State of some of you. You'll turn on a sixpence with nary a second of thought

I've always championed Gibson. When fit, a class above McCarthy. Why has he not even been selected for cameos?
 
Players are just robots to some. There isn't such thing as being in or out of form, they are either good or bad players.

Can't understand it, myself.

Players are untouchable to some. There isn't such things as being in or out of form, they are either good or good players.

Can't understand it myself.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top