James McCarthy

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mcgeadys a poor mans sterling can run and run but no end product, would rather another winger on loan with a CM like Fernando coming in permantly and a striker and CB if jelavic and Heitinga leave
 

Mcgeadys a poor mans sterling can run and run but no end product, would rather another winger on loan with a CM like Fernando coming in permantly and a striker and CB if jelavic and Heitinga leave
Agree with this - I'd like to see Zaha on loan rather than McGeady.
 
I actually wouldn't mind McGeady in all honesty.

I seem to remember him being fairly decent. He's desperate to get away from there and prove himself in a top league and his contract is up in the summer so he'd be cheap. He'd have three (four including Duffy) Irish buddies here too.

At worst he'd be an upgrade on Naismith, in my opinion.
 

I don't think there's a chance in hell Zaha will come to us on loan. Mainly because knowing Moyes he'd be sh*tting himself in case he came good and Roberto made him look like a divvy again.
 
If I havent watched a player I normally read what other people say and go with what most people say.

Most people have said hes hyper tosh.
I thought with your intimate knowledge of the game and incredible ability to see talent, you would have made your own mind up. Disappointed tbh.
 
Agree with this - I'd like to see Zaha on loan rather than McGeady.

No, I don't really rate McGeady but I think zaha is a bit TOO raw to be as useful as we need. VERY promising player but I'd rather Bobby got some random basque 30 year old who's in with a sniff of the Spain squad, someone who could come in and really impress straight away like Barry has.
 


Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top