James McCarthy - Signed on deadline day for reported £13m

[Essex Blue]

Oh my word, what a joke!

 

[Bigmaclad]

I see Whelan is playing his role as our communications officer again

 

[dannyboy]

But like the Utd forums when we signed Gibson

Except not being good enough for United is completely different to not being highly rated by Wigan fans.

 

[tsubaki]

Still not hearing these McCarthy alternatives....the fancy dans who cost London clubs less because they pay them top dollar in wages....leave them aside and who are we looking at lads?

Porto bought Defour for six million euro a couple of seasons ago.

 

[MACCA75]

But like the Utd forums when we signed Gibson

Gibson wasnt meant to be United's star player though was he. He's not good enough for United at the end of the day.

 

[chicoazul]

Morrison yes would be good

Beattie as our next manager mate?

 

[orly]

Would you have Michael Carrick at Everton mate?

Do we spend 10m on him?

 

[davek]

hahahahahahahhaha

BUT MATE HE IZ PAZZING THE BALL TO DER WINGHERS ALBEIT VERY SLOWLY BUT THAT IS THE TEMPO

The funny thing is you cant see the impact he's having there....

Hilarious.

 

[Essex Blue]

If he was any good spurs would have signed him, seeing as they have signed every midfielder this season already

Very true. Spurs aren't remotely interested in this James McFadden effort.

 

[Quim]

I wouldn't be to worried by someone hand picking some quotes from a Wigan forum to prove a point.

 

[KUEFC09U2]

Genuinely think I give up for some of our support

 

[Del]

500k Gibson from Manchester United

10m+ McCarthy from relegated Wigan.

Hmm... can see a flaw in your logic.

What does price have to do with it?

Utd fans said Gibson was an awful awful player and everyone on here said "Oh my god this lad is crap look what there saying"

Same as what the Wigan fans are saying now

TBH I am not really that arsed, What will be will be, Nothing you or I say will change what happens in the next 24 hours will it

Just get behind the lad if he signs and see how it turns out

 

[MACCA75]

Why aren't we in for Cabaye?!
I do think the lad is a bit overrated -
and maybe it's too late with Arsenal
having turned his head, but having
Pienaar, Gibson, Cabaye and Mirallas
with Ross behind a striker would be
decent, Cabaye would cost less than
Felli and most likely earn less as well.

I like this McCarthy lad, but whatever
Dave Whelan wants for him will be too
much.

Not a bad shout actually.

 

[Greek Fisherman]

I see Whelan is playing his role as our communications officer again

Good on him, at least Wigan doesn't have a chairman who hides behind their manager because they're skint!

McCarthy would be a good singing if he was playing alongside Fellaini. As his replacement? Sickening.

 

[orly]

The funny thing is you cant see the impact he's having there....

Hilarious.

oh no but you see I can.

He loses the ball lots.

He slows down the play.

He creates nothing.

He's left a wonderfully clear impression on me - just like his stats from last season!

Good going Davek... keep digging...