2023/24 James Garner

[MACCA75]

That was awful. Completely anonymous and hopefully we never see him there again. Think he’s on the bench next game tbh.

 

[Baggzio]

Think that’s the last we’ll see him on the right anyways just because McNeil will be fully fit after the break. I’d imagine Harrison probably will be as well.

 

[Everton_Gary]

Play him in behind the strikers. Not a winger. Yet to really play him where he excelled before we bought him.

 

[maccavennie]

That was an absolutely dreadful performance that.

Not surprised considering he's looked absolutely crap being stuck out there by Dyche

 

[Chrismac]

Seems scared to get involved and take any risks.
Definitely doesn't suit out wide.
If he gets the chance in the middle he really needs to affect the game more.

 

[Zatara]

Dyche single handedly trying to ruin the boys career.

 

[Rita_Poon]

I thought he got stuck in and it was his ability to fight past the foul that helped us gain a yard to exploit.

 

[Bebeto]

Think that’s the last we’ll see him on the right anyways just because McNeil will be fully fit after the break. I’d imagine Harrison probably will be as well.

Don't worry, somebody else will be injured as this is the everton way...couple of internationals coming up so interesting to see which ones will come back injured.

 

[EFC_FRANCIS]

Hes just not as good as people think he is. But aside from that he's absolutely not a winger. Mills would be better there

 

[blulouie]

I really like this lad .....but

Not had the best of starts to the season , maybe the World Cup has took a lot out of him.
Atm doesn't have the legs to get up & down the line.
Rightfully subbed today.

 

[Nymzee]

He's just not a right mid that's all.

 

[roy vernon]

He was poor today, not through any fault of his own, rather it was the fault of Dyche and the people who think it's a good idea to play Gueye in central midfield and play Garner at either right midfield or right back. I don't care what England under 21s or @davek think, he is not a full back or a winger he is a midfielder and needs to be allowed to develop there. Gueye is a liability, get him out and let the much better player, Garner, have a chance to develop in that role.

Playing kids in many positions very rarely helps their development.

 

[Gilbert..]

Hes just not as good as people think he is. But aside from that he's absolutely not a winger. Mills would be better there

Ive tried not to comment much as i think there is improvement but i do think he gets over rated comments at times. Hes ok.

 

[Willo62]

This lad is being played out of position, so I can’t believe how much people on here are slagging him off.
He’s the only central midfielder we have with any composure on the ball, and a good range of passing. But he needs a good run of games in his rightful position.
Many Man Utd fans were gutted when he left, because they had heard good things about him for years in the youth teams.
He was excellent for Forest in their promotion season, and they would have bought him on a permanent deal, had they not spent most of their budget on Gibbs-White.

 

[nffcn]

This lad is being played out of position, so I can’t believe how much people on here are slagging him off.
He’s the only central midfielder we have with any composure on the ball, and a good range of passing. But he needs a good run of games in his rightful position.
Many Man Utd fans were gutted when he left, because they had heard good things about him for years in the youth teams.
He was excellent for Forest in their promotion season, and they would have bought him on a permanent deal, had they not spent most of their budget on Gibbs-White.

Hi guys I am a Forest fan, I am baffled he is being played on right for you guys.

For us in the Championship he was a sitter that dictated the game from deep and did so really well with a good range of passing & intensity with Ryan Yates next to him who is massive & all action, basically did his donkey work. (Kinda like Onana could maybe do for you guys? Although I am not going to lecture you on how to use players you know better than me)

We would have signed him but it wasn't to do with Gibbs-White - Man United really messed us around as they wanted to take a look at him in pre-season, but we had nobody so we ended up signing Orel Mangala instead as we wouldn't have had a midfielder in time for the season start.