He'll do 15 years at Goodison in the end. I'm pretty certain he'll have won nothing in his time here, and that will have to be seen as failure by anyone reasonable. Fair enough, cash hasn't been lavished on him, but then neither was it on Joe Royle who did pick up a trophy, and (as mentioned before about Moyes) he'll have been a 'time rich' manager who'd have had sufficient time to build two or three strong sides to get it right and snatch one of the domestic cups.
The PR machine will tell you we've been lucky to have him etc etc. Truth is, he's been extremely fortunate to have us as well. His feet wouldn't have touched in an ambitious Everton organisation of the past.