Go for Nani

[Dixies60]

He does have talent, he's got more skill and naturally ability than the majority of our squad. His main problem is his decision making, he makes alot of bad decisions and his end product is very hit and miss.

A lot of young wingers have this problem though, especially quick wingers. Playing week in week out would without doubt help him. People forget that every once and a while he comes into the Manchester Utd side and is expected to produce. It’s not always that easy.

I’d without doubt take him, he’s a rough diamond and someone who could do well under David Moyes and Steve Round. Not for 12 million though, that’s too expensive. A loan would be great.

100% agree.

 

[Nebbiolo]

I think TB is right. A loan would be ideal, and we could see whether he really is the world-class player that Ferguson thought. He's a winger by trade (I think), so would give us that much presence their. Him and Pienaar on the wings might something beautiful to watch.

It depends on our budget really. I think if Nani is brought in, it will be after he feels assured that he's not just going to sit on the bench every week. If we do have a shed load of cash, and finally purchase Moutinho (Mout often plays on the wing as well) I can't see Nani being that interested. Why leave a club like United to to go to the same situation at Everton?

 

[Dixies60]

If he joined us he would be an automatic first choice.

 

[Nebbiolo]

If he joined us he would be an automatic first choice.

Thing is, although our midfield can be a little disjointed, if we add Moutinho and Nani, we'll have an embarrassment of riches.

Pienaar, Fellaini, Cahill, Arteta, Rodwell, Moutinho, Nani

(Not included Neville)

That would be 7 players, competing for 5 (maybe 4) slots. I'm not sure, therefore, that Nani would be an automatic first choice.

The obvious two to be reserves would be Cahill/Fellaini and Rodwell

Maybe I'm wrong ...