Everton/Man Utd XI versus Everton/Rangers XI (Who Beats Who?)

[blue to the bone]

Then don't read it or comment on it, I think threads like this are good and can spark some interesting discussions.

I'll do what I like mate .

 

[Connor]

No way the Everton/United team are keeping a clean sheet, state of the defense it's worse than our current defense even includes one of them.

7-0

 

[Tipp blue]

I'll do what I like mate .

Fair enough seems odd to me that you'll come onto a thread you don't like the look of just to complain about it.

 

[blue to the bone]

Fair enough seems odd to me that you'll come onto a thread you don't like the look of just to complain about it.

I would have only commented once If you had not decided to play mod and tag me .

 

[Tipp blue]

I would have only commented once If you had not decided to play mod and tag me .

LOL

 

[Diogenes the Cynic]

I'd have loved to have seen peak Gazza playing against peak Rooney.

 

[ArtetaMoney]

Best thread I’ve seen on here for a while. I’ll go for the Rangers team but only cos they’ve got more subs.

 

[Debunkology]

The rangers defence is better than the United defence, but United’s midfield and attack are much better. I’d remove Saha and have Rooney upfront with Lukaku tho, and have Beardsley as number 10 with Kanchelskis on the right with Fellaini and Neville in CM, but then you’d have to find players to play left midfield and left back.

Although that might actually lead to a 4-5-2 formation lol.

Go 3-5-2 with an unknown left winger then.

If Rooney goes in attack over Saha. You'd still take Neville as CM over Schneiderlin? Blomqvist was a leftwinger. But a squad player.

 

[argietoffee]

Nobody really believes this, Ted, do they?

 

[Debunkology]

How the hell has this thread come to fruition...

Someone sent me a link to a quiz (name all the players who played for both Everton Man Utd). I only got half of them. And somehow missed Lukaku.

And one of the others was Rangers. It went from there.

 

[Exeter_Gently]

Someone sent me a link to a quiz (name all the players who played for both Everton Man Utd). I only got half of them. And somehow missed Lukaku.

And one of the others was Rangers. It went from there.

Fair enough mate.

 

[Dymak]

If Rooney goes in attack over Saha. You'd still take Neville as CM over Schneiderlin? Blomqvist was a leftwinger. But a squad player.

Schneiderlin is a disgrace to the Everton shirt mate. Neville was a worthy captain and a good defensive midfielder imo. There's no doubt I'd have Neville over Schneilderlin. I'd have almost anyone over Schneiderlin, whereas I'd have Neville over many of our CM's. Neville in his prime would walk into our midfield right now.

 

[ToffeeDan]

That Everton United defence looks pretty awful. And for anyone who ignores a side with Tricky Trev in it...

 

[Khalekan]

Everton/Man Utd XI

Manager: David Moyes

Tim Howard
Gidman - O'Kane - Keane - Neville
Fellaini
Kanchelskis - Rooney - Beardsley
Romelu Lukaku - Louis Saha

Subs -
Gibson
Schneiderlin
Mark Hughes
Norman Whiteside
Jesper Blomqvist
Cleverley

versus

Rangers/Everton XI

Manager: Walter Smith

Myhre
Stevens - Gough - Weir - Ball
Steven - Arteta - Gascoigne - McCall
Gray - Ferguson

Subs
Simonsen
Durrant
Clelland
Mo Johnston
Senderos
Kanchelskis
Spencer
Naismith
Jeffers
Rideout
Jelavic
Beattie


Thoughts?

Keane?


At centre half?

Have you never heard of Mark Higgins?

 

[Tel001]

Everton/United for sure. A front two of Lukaku and Saha would be absolutely disgraceful too

Was thinking lukaku and Rooney partnership