I think it would have been very easy for Vibert and Sqaurepusher to make bog standard DnB that would have destroyed the "scene" but they were already involved in more cutting edge genres that were pushing production to new levels. Instead they made DnB tracks at the time that said "How the frig are they doing that...",
I agree with this (Squarepusher more so)
when I listen to Nosia tunes, I don't wonder how they are making that, it is pretty simple stuff with selection of sounds being key.
It's definitely not pretty simple although it may sound like that to someone who isn't aware of the complexities of producing this type of music to a very high level. The amount of work that goes into making it sound how it does is insane, they have absolutely mastered their craft, of this there is no doubt.
There is a reason they have the reputation they do, there is a reason they have done sound design for hollywood films, they are incredibly talented producers regardless of whether you like their music.
You are talking about clarity and selection of sounds somehow surpassing creative ideas and production techniques never heard before in a genre of music, each to their own I guess but I know what fascinates me more and I make my own tracks and know what goes into production.
Im not sure what gave you this impression, I've certainly not suggested this anywhere in my posts. I'm a full believer that ideas and creativity come before production, Burial being a perfect example of this.
With that said i definitely care more about production than the average person simply because im a production nerd who studied audio engineering. I admire great production regardless of whether i love the music or not similar to how i admire Joe Satriani's technical ability on a guitar whilst disliking his music at the same time.