A 10 man defence negates any space for the attacking team, Jose being the great tactical manager he is , used the tools he had at his disposal to overcome the negative tactic employed byou klopp thus enabling United to capitalise. It really is that simple. Maybe klopp can take a valuable lesson from the game about shutting up shop at 50 minutes and expecting to see it out.It may be effective but do any of the other 'top' teams' resort to it? Especially against a crap defence.