As long as there's no exact repetition of season 2004/05!!
That's done.
Say what you want about Benitez, but he was calm under pressure and knew how to win big games. Benitez would have got a result tonight, a 1-1 and would have recognised they have avoided all the top teams and got them to the final.
Klopp hasnt got that skill. He still bottles big games, his record in finals remains atrocious and in cup comps more generally is awful.
If you look at the 2 trophies he won, 1 was a freak season where their fans weren't allowed in to jeopardise it like they usually would (and have previously) with their unique brand of knobheadery. It was a freak season where City took a year off for transition, having had an injury crisis far worse than the one they keep whining about.
The other was when they played the arch bottlers Spurs, and managed to avoid Juventus, Ajax, Madrid x 2, Bayern & PSG on their route to the final who all knock them out with ease. A jammy run and then playing the only team in English football who are even bigger bottlers than Klopp (and us to be fair)- Spurs.
He basically has to get so far ahead to win something its unreal. He has no idea how to win ugly, and he cuts a manic figure.
Houllier and Benitez would have got them to the final.