2025/26 David Moyes

[AdamMcG2000]

It’s crazy how close we are to that top 6, if we’d have got over the line in numerous games we’d be primed for a top 6 spot. That’s the problem though as it always has been with Moyes, more often than not we don’t get over the line when it matters

 

[PercyPlant]

Yes, a better manager at Everton would win trophies.

If Carlo had over 14 seasons at Everton he would have won us a few trophies.

So you think Carlo Ancelotti would spend 14 years at Everton under Bill Kenwright. Christ. I almost feel sorry for you. No realism in your head at all.

 

[blulouie]

 

[PercyPlant]

You did ask " Would a better manager at Everton win us trophies"

My answer is yes, Moyes has won us nothing. Anyone who wins a trophy is simply better.

Carlo Ancelotti couldn’t get us top half with James Rodriguez and a 20 goal striker. Try harder.

 

[Moomin]

We wasnt winning not under Moshiri and that board

Neither would Moyes

Carlo is multi levels above Moyes

Moyes is on a level with Pulis, Dyche and the other negative dinosaurs.

 

[windymiller]

Everyone hopes for better. But I see a squad that has missed its best CB for 70% of the season, has no full backs and no strikers and lost its most creative player for 1/2 of the season. It’s wild that he’s being hammered when he’s the first manager in 1/2 a decade to have our entire fanbase convinced relegation isn’t a problem.

I haven't hammered him there, I said he was fine. He decided not to sign any fullbacks last summer and a lot of people said that was a mistake at the time. It's odd to claim that a lack of fullbacks is the issue as if Moyes had no say in that. He should've signed a right back, and was linked with Tete, but he didn't. That is a point of criticism for Moyes, not a mitigating factor, in my opinion.

 

[Melcher]

What does me using a cup upset, to reference the above trolls nonsense, have to do with Moyes and his time at United?

Who's talking about Moyes at united? That's a genuine question, I don't understand your reference.

You've just said united were reigning league and European champions and then got knocked out the fa cup by Portsmouth. What's that got to do with Moyes?

 

[Moomin]

Carlo Ancelotti couldn’t get us top half with James Rodriguez and a 20 goal striker. Try harder.

Imagine trying to say Moyes is better than Ancellotti?

Like trying to say Lee Cattermole is better than Zidane.

Very pathetic and sad Ian.

 

[MikeH72]

Hopefully next time he leaves we won’t go on to be an absolute skip fire for the next 10 years and need him to pick us back out of the gutter for a third time.

 

[Moomin]

So you think Carlo Ancelotti would spend 14 years at Everton under Bill Kenwright. Christ. I almost feel sorry for you. No realism in your head at all.

No, he is a winner.

Unlike Moyes.

 

[Moomin]

Who's talking about Moyes at united? That's a genuine question, I don't understand your reference.

You've just said united were reigning league and European champions and then got knocked out the fa cup by Portsmouth. What's that got to do with Moyes?

He is a bit strange.

Massive fan of Florida and Donald Trump.

You do the maths.

 

[Thomasc]

No, he is a winner.

Unlike Moyes.

We all know Moyes isn’t a winner.

He’s a competent PL manager.

Time to roll the dice again and see which manager can get us back to trying to win a cup, because that’s the ultimate we can aim for these days due to how the PL Is structured.

If we end up with another one season wonder like Martinez though, don’t be moaning.

 

[PercyPlant]

Imagine trying to say Moyes is better than Ancellotti?

Like trying to say Lee Cattermole is better than Zidane.

Very pathetic and sad Ian.

You’re really good at what you do, no doubt about it, but this is so pathetically weak it’s untrue. Try much much harder. #strawman

 

[PercyPlant]

No, he is a winner.

Unlike Moyes.

11th place with James isn’t winning.

 

[Moomin]

We all know Moyes isn’t a winner.

He’s a competent PL manager.

Time to roll the dice again and see which manager can get us back to trying to win a cup, because that’s the ultimate we can aim for these days due to how the PL Is structured.

If we end up with another one season wonder like Martinez though, don’t be moaning.

I'm happy to try that.

Moyes is Moyes, would like to move on in the summer and leave on a good note.