He takes up a place in the squad though doesn't he?
That's a spot we could give to someone who is actually fit to play more than ten times a season and who doesn't get drunk at night and go running cyclists over in his mornings.
No, though, you're absolutely right you boss blue you. He's clearly done more than enough to deserve to be here and to be paid a footballer's wages despite not taking care of his body like a footballer should or even being available to play football more than 25% of the season. I can see why you'd be happy. He's proper NSNO, just like you, you utterly boss blue.
Calling other fans bedwetters because you don't agree with them kicking off over someone who can't be relied upon being handed a new contract.
Here's a few reasons to keep him.
I think he was fit for pretty much most of last season.
He counts as a home grown player.
He's only 28.
Makes business sense to have him on a contract and sell on if it doesn't work out than let him go for free and pay a premium for a home grown squad filler.
Any player who isn't coming close to retirement deserves a chance under the new management.
Having Gibson at the club could be another reason for Rooney to switch from united.
He was Evertons best player when Koeman last saw us a few months ago.
He has experience of winning the premier league.
Here's a few reasons to let him go.
Poor fitness.
Poor off field behavior
I think it make sense to keep him, at least till Koeman has had a chance to assess him properly.