BIGGEST DISAPPOINTMENT?

alan ball · May 31, 2014

Which player that came to Everton failed to live up to the standards that was expected which left you so disappointed with him. For me it could be either Andy Johnson or James Beattie but again Steffan Rehn was struggling when he came into the side. Interesting to hear your thoughts on this

Eric Djemba-Djemba · May 31, 2014

Bily for me. Big fee, looked boss on youtube and had a fancy foreign name. Thought he was going to be boss.

evertony · May 31, 2014

Stephen Hughes from Arsenal

toffeejack · May 31, 2014

yakubu if you're being harsh.

the injury ruined him like, but we sold him for way too low, i would have kept hold of him rather than selling for a measly £1.5m

toffeejack · May 31, 2014

pienaar's been average since coming back, but he won't go down as the biggest dissapointment.

van der meyde is up there for me, as is drenthe, but i think with a better manager he would have been a success

potato · May 31, 2014

jack rodwell

had high hopes for him but turned out to be another dud. Due to a solo goal he scored against utd we were able to hoodwink city into spending a fortune for an average player.

chicoazul · May 31, 2014

John Collins or Slaven Bilic.

maccavennie · May 31, 2014

Slaven Bilic springs to mind, Per Koldrup, Van Der Meyde as 3 who spring to mind

toffeejack · May 31, 2014

johnson was great though, made a profit as well, wouldn't call his everton career a dissapointment, definitely agree with beattie though. always liked him, but just knew in the back of my mind he wouldn't succeed at such a big club like ours.

Minimeister · May 31, 2014

my wedding night.

tonyhorne · May 31, 2014

Mike Millighan

toffeejack · May 31, 2014

Minimeister said:
my wedding night.

ale house mate

maccavennie · May 31, 2014

chicoazul said:
John Collins or Slaven Bilic.

John Collins is a strange one Chico. I thought he was absolutely gash for ages and then just when I thought he was turning the corner and showing his true colours he swanned off the bad scruff

chicoazul · May 31, 2014

maccavennie said:
John Collins is a strange one Chico. I thought he was absolutely gash for ages and then just when I thought he was turning the corner and showing his true colours he swanned off the bad scruff

Defo mate but Everton in general at that time was just horrible anyway maybe we rubbed off.

toffeejack · May 31, 2014

olivier dacourt always peed me off, thought he could have been so much better.

seeing how his career turned out, matterazzi was a huge dissapointment for us, could have been so much better for us