2022/23 Ben Godfrey

[carolinablue232]

I’m not sure who’s worse between Godfrey, Keane, and Holgate. Just keep whoever is on the lowest wage as a backup and bin the other two. They’re all liabilities.

 

[GoldenToffee]

Definitely sell alongside Keane and Holgate. I know this won't happen, but neither one of them are anywhere near good enough... just compare them to Tarkowski. And Holgate and Godfrey should never be known as versatile players as they're crap at full back. Sell all three.

 

[GoldenToffee]

I’m not sure who’s worse between Godfrey, Keane, and Holgate. Just keep whoever is on the lowest wage as a backup and bin the other two. They’re all liabilities.

Essentially it may have to be that as we won't be able to sell all three, sadly.

 

[maccavennie]

Had such a good first season under Ancelotti, looked athletic and had powers of recovery.

The way he was skinned against Newcastle was embarrassing though I've got a feeling he was injured at that point but decided not to tell anyone.

He's regressed though and not kicked on. He's another footballer who unfortunately can't actually play football. Dreadful with the ball at his feet

It's imperative we move on the likes of him, Holgate, Keane and Davies this summer.

 

[ToffeeTim]

Find a buyer and sell. Not a good enough defender

 

[paultheblue]

I’m not sure who’s worse between Godfrey, Keane, and Holgate. Just keep whoever is on the lowest wage as a backup and bin the other two. They’re all liabilities.

If we have to keep one it has to be Godfrey as unless we get a fee of over 10/11 million It will impact on the FFP.
Holgate we can show a profit and Keane would be a profit over 5m.

 

[Tel001]

So was Holgate

And davies

Think even traffic Kone had his time in the sunshine at some point

 

[Kirkles]

He's gone backwards , not a CB and not a full back. Needs binning off with Holgate.

 

[Simon Buttle]

He's gone backwards , not a CB and not a full back. Needs binning off with Holgate.

He is what he is, a lower league player. There is a bit of something there but it's not PL level and tbh I'm not even sure it's Championship level.

 

[Dario Terracotta]

He is what he is, a lower league player. There is a bit of something there but it's not PL level and tbh I'm not even sure it's Championship level.

He’s had some decent games at times like Holgate,thought he was excellent at City last season up against Haaland,also the Covid derby at the pit,but too inconsistent at this level,can’t rely on him.

 

[Bristol Blue]

Not a prem player, same as Holgate and Keane. Somehow Carlo managed to squeeze some kind of performance out of all of them, whilst we played some of the most depressing football ever. Decent fee and I’d get him gone.

 

[BenToffee79]

Ship out , wigans only
Joy was down his side , just a bad signing, Scotland be ideal for him

 

[knowing your history]

Holgate's the only one likely to move you suspect, not sure if that Sheffield United link has died out now but should be a few clubs interested in the championship.

Keane and Holgate are going to play a fair bit in the early months of the season you suspect.

 

[banno]

Would rather get rid of Godfrey than Holgate if one of them had to be kept otherwise get rid of both

 

[Gilbert..]

Few times today the wigan player dropped his shoulder and Godfrey bought it and was so flat footed.
Nothing to do with pre season. He'll be like it half way through the season aswell.
Nothings changed. I like his attitude. He cant defend though. And its been that way since day 1. An awful 25m outlay.