Andy Carroll - Linked with £10million move to Newcastle - Should we match???

[TheFinnFan]

Negredo is the answer. The Spaniard will lead us into the promise land

nah, Welbeck, though

 

[Elong]

he is pretty much the same player as Ferguson, apart from he looks a tit and isn't that scary. When he plays well, he is unplayable just like Ferguson, but half the time he isn't interested. 10m is too much of a gamble. 7 or 8 maybe

Not fit to tie Big Dunc's laces lad.

 

[AaronTheBlue]

I actually think he'd be really food for us, I'd quite like him, But i don't think it'd be financially suitable.

 

[ART]

Go full hog a make a bid for Rooney he would be good back up for Carrol. God help us.

 

[Christiffa25]

If were keeping Vic and jelavic then No as he's a simlar big target man type of player. If one of them were to move on and the price was right then maybe yeah.

As said if were keeping the two we have we need a different type of striker coming in. More of a Rooney No.10 type or a pacy Remy type.

 

[MartSlinger]

Carroll: £10m
orrrrrr
Negredo: £13-15m?

I know which one id choose. As i said yesterday in the 'Strikers Wanted' thread, strikers like Carroll arent good enough for us to be able to push for the Champions League again next season, simple as that.

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

I actually think he'd be really food for us, I'd quite like him, But i don't think it'd be financially suitable.

Horsemeat scandal has passed now lad.

 

[edge]

to much money for us, and not producing it in enough games , saying that young enough to learn not bad for that price

 

[Groucho]

To be honest, a former Liverpool player, if good enough would not bother me. In fact it'd just make it all the more fun if he were to score against them. But, as Elong says;

Not fit to tie Big Dunc's laces lad.

 

[blueblue]

We couldn't afford the deal,specially his financial demands. Liverpool would rather see him retire than sell him to us in fear of him being a big success.

However,I think he is a decent player and would do very well at Everton,he plays the kind of centreforward role that supporters(at least this one likes). I think Brendan Rogers doesn't want a big bustling centreforward near his team and he will move to West Ham or Newcastle this summer. West

 

[Frank Drebin]

Let's just do what we always do and offer 2 million less after they have their bid accepted.

 

[phildp]

Taking away the stupid fee and that he is a RS, i've always thought in the past he would work really well in our team. But i do think there have been times this season when we have shown a less direct style and this is what we still need to strive for to compete more so we need more cultured players than him. So it is a big no from me now, tho being realistic if we matched Newcastles offer he wouldn't come to us anyway.

 

[Pabbers]

We are getting Rooney next season anyway.

 

[royalblue66]

That good info like

 

[Pabbers]

Not at all mate.