@sc1878 has detailed the basic role of a DOF which is generally accepted at most other clubs.
Its clear and obvious that Everton arent following the DOF model and aside from the title there is little similarity between our DOF and other clubs'.
A fan can tell you that from simply reading about DOFs at other clubs and watching videos on youtube where the role is explained.
The role of a DOF will vary from club to club depending on the owner/chairman and of course the manager as well.
Even then in reality we have absolutely no idea what power or influence Brands has at the club.
Straight question and straight answer please.
What role did Brands play in the appointment of the manager.... no opinions or quotes from some journalist expressing an opinion or poster on here doing the same.
What role did Brands play in appointing the manager.
The answer in my opinion.... none of us know.
So based on what are people making judgements ?
We know JR came to Everton because of CA he has already said this. I think it fair to say Allan came for the same reason.
CA said he knew nothing about Godfrey and very little about Doucoure so we can say they were Brands signings based on what was said by the individuals.
Other than that kind of detail people are taking guesswork and trying to dress it up as fact.