Aiden McGeady

[The Equaliser]

Awful, awful player.

One of the worst I've ever seen play for Everton.

He's a good player who is maybe a bit inconsistent to make it at Everton but that is way OTT boss.

 

[applecrumble]

The club that takes McGeady of our hands will forever win a special place in my heart.

 

[Chang Elephant]

Awful, awful player.

One of the worst I've ever seen play for Everton.

Now this is what an opinion looks like

 

[GrandOldTeam]

He's a good player who is maybe a bit inconsistent to make it at Everton but that is way OTT boss.

Good player?

Really?

For me, the worst 'winger' we've had a permanent transfer since Simon Davies.

 

[The Equaliser]

Good player?

Really?

For me, the worst 'winger' we've had a permanent transfer since Simon Davies.

Which wasn't that long ago.

But you said he was one of the worst players ever to play for Everton, which is a tad OTT.

 

[davek]

Good player?

Really?

For me, the worst 'winger' we've had a permanent transfer since Simon Davies.

van der Meyde?

 

[Goat]

van der Meyde?

He was much better, even on a Saturday night in the bogs.

 

[GrandOldTeam]

Which wasn't that long ago.

But you said he was one of the worst players ever to play for Everton, which is a tad OTT.

No, no. If you're going to tell me what I said, at least get it right.

I said one of the worst I've ever seen play for Everton.

I maintain my opinion.

 

[GrandOldTeam]

van der Meyde?

On the pitch, considerably better.

His contribution to Goslings goal vs Liverpool and subsequent celebration alone was better than anything the poor mans James McFadden has done.

 

[MikeH72]

I can actually think of 3 or 4 occasions when he's come off the bench and his directness and crossing ability has resulted in us scoring a goal and winning a match. Consistently miserable whenever he actually starts matches though

 

[MikeH72]

On the pitch, considerably better.

His contribution to Goslings goal vs Liverpool and subsequent celebration alone was better than anything the poor mans James McFadden has done.

McGeady provided Coleman's last minute winner against Cardiff the season before last, he set up Lukaku's last minute winner against West Ham a couple of months ago, he scored a decent goal against Leicester. He's done more for us than van der Meyde did in 4 years. Not saying he's ultimately good enough for us, by the way

 

[davek]

On the pitch, considerably better.

His contribution to Goslings goal vs Liverpool and subsequent celebration alone was better than anything the poor mans James McFadden has done.

Van Der Meyde was appaling. He had one 45 minute purple patch in a game against West Ham and that was about the sum total of his contribution.

He was a disaster on the pitch. There's no way he put in a better shift than McGeady.

This is getting seriously bizarre now.

 

[GrandOldTeam]

McGeady provided Coleman's last minute winner against Cardiff the season before last, he set up Lukaku's last minute winner against West Ham a couple of months ago, he scored a decent goal against Leicester. He's done more for us than van der Meyde did in 4 years. Not saying he's ultimately good enough for us, by the way

van der Meyde had undoubted quality. Like Drenthe.

But just absolute tools.

 

[The Equaliser]

No, no. If you're going to tell me what I said, at least get it right.

I said one of the worst I've ever seen play for Everton.

I maintain my opinion.

Oh with your own eyes you mean ? Alright then.

*sigh

 

[GrandOldTeam]

Van Der Meyde was appaling. He had one 45 minute purple patch in a game against West Ham and that was about the sum total of his contribution.

He was a disaster on the pitch. There's no way he put in a better shift than McGeady.

This is getting seriously bizarre now.

The very fact your using van der Meyde alone as the single player worse than McGeady speaks volumes.