2025/26 Charly Alcaraz

[Starface]

Still think he’s the one that will probably do something.

Something terrible?

 

[Victus]

This is an embarrassing and hyperbolic stance , he is not an awful footballer lol you can state he's not effective or he has flaws in his game but to claim hes terrible is ludicrous

Your mate is stinking the gaff out again. Genuinely an awful awful player.

 

[toffeeblue9]

Your mate is stinking the gaff out again. Genuinely an awful awful player.

My favourite argument is that he's being "misused"

He's being misused by being on the pitch from my pov

 

[Zatara]

What has actually happened to him….he used to be a fairly good player

Moyes happened.

 

[Zatara]

My favourite argument is that he's being "misused"

He's being misused by being on the pitch from my pov

If you cant see the difference now compared with before then...

Of course hes been mistreated.

 

[BlueStevie35]

Are people willing to admit he’s just average? He’ll have games where he’ll pull a bit of magic out but he’s had far more like that that first half where he makes simple passes go haywire

 

[windymiller]

He holds on to the ball for way too long. He really needs to start laying it off much more quickly. There has been a few occasions when Dibling and Iroegbunam (of all people) have been free but instead of releasing them he's held onto the ball, got dispossessed and the move breaks down.

 

[maccavennie]

He's got into some great positions with the ball and been absolitely dreadful with it.

 

[toffeeblue9]

If you cant see the difference now compared with before then...

Of course hes been mistreated.

If you mean Vs last season?

Last season we were fighting for our lives and playing on the break a lot, so he didn't have to do much other than help us in transition.

This season we are trying to get on the ball and play a bit, so if your argument is that he's being misused by being asked to play a bit more football then we are better off without him. Funnily enough this is exactly the conclusion his last manager and club came to.

 

[Victus]

He's got into some great positions with the ball and been absolitely dreadful with it.

he does it loads, its like he forgets to press the pass button.

 

[maccavennie]

he does it loads, its like he forgets to press the pass button.

He might be using an old xbox controller

 

[Starface]

Are people willing to admit he’s just average? He’ll have games where he’ll pull a bit of magic out but he’s had far more like that that first half where he makes simple passes go haywire

Mistreated!

 

[pfim]

Needs to lead the counter attacks with more conviction. None of these guys are making a case for more playing time, and he’s definitely part of that group

 

[Davideeyore]

Disappointed with his out put

 

[Frosty1878]

If you cant see the difference now compared with before then...

Of course hes been mistreated.

It’s OK to be wrong on a player, it’s fine to admit he’s average, it’s always someone else’s fault other than the actual player just isn’t great. Wrong position wrong tactics boots too tight or just plain and simple