Summer Transfer Window 2025 Thread


I have no idea. Just think Longstaff is crap and he is a sub at Newcastle. Ndidi rejected us before and is almost 29 and has regressed.

Ndidi has actually been very good the last 2 years. He was one of the only Leicester players who performed last season. I wouldn’t hate signing him for Ā£8/9m but I’m not particularly excited by the prospect
 

Newcastle have a fantastic midfield though, so being sub is no stick to beat him with, lad is a decent (not great but solid) player.
He isn't mate, his numbers are worse than Garners and he needs replacing. CM needs to be an upgrade not another sticking plaster/kick the can down the road type. CM and RW were always the key positions for me.
 

Dave, hand on heart mate, do you honestly believe we, after all our financial issues, would drop Ā£30m on a player just to loan him out? Come on you’re better than that
Buying and loaning could have same cost from a PSR perspective, difference is when you buy you have an asset available for a new contract or future sale, a loan is cost with no underlying asset. (i.e. the loan fee could be similar cost as the amortisation.)
 
Newcastle have a fantastic midfield though, so being sub is no stick to beat him with, lad is a decent (not great but solid) player.
The issue with Longstaff is that he is a little bit of everything. Box to box with lots of energy, not great on the ball but decent defensively.

The type of player it would make sense to look into if we played with a three man midfield. The number 8 position that suits Longstaff doesn't exist in Everton's team.

We have arguably the worst midfield in the league when it comes to technical quality on the ball. Playing a Longstaff instead of Garner would make it significantly worse.

That said, I expect the Longstaff's and Soucek's of this world to be looked at as 10's by Moyes. As Doucoure upgrades. He'll play them over Alcaraz every day of the week.
 
I think its a good thing as they would only have been stop gaps and it shows we were unwilling to pay over the odds like we would have done previously. Quite refreshing really...
Suppose it depends on your pov. I just find it yet another in a long line of embarrassments.
 

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top