Hinchcliffe's Corner
Player Valuation: £50m
Especially when the answer is O'Brien.
GrandOldSte117
Player Valuation: £25m
You have not yet had the MikeH72 experience
Blast_of_Cannock
Player Valuation: £15m
It's not really fair on the lad comparing him with Young, he's still got another 16 years of improving to reach that level.
He barely gets touched in the face for their equaliser.
Needs to get up, do his job and defend and then kick off at the ref.
Even if he was up though, he'd only have been in the same position as Harrison so wouldn't have been able to challenge. Jakes at fault for the goal.
Needs to get up, do his job and defend and then kick off at the ref.
Even if he was up though, he'd only have been in the same position as Harrison so wouldn't have been able to challenge. Jakes at fault for the goal.
Me too, this clown has been the most divisive player we've ever had. For zero returns.
Some of the comments are great to be honest 
Anyway, he should get away as there's a chunk of the fanbase that hates him based on nothing, but adores players who were in a similar positions and underperformed even worse, in a team that wasn't in several relegation fights in a row. He'll likely improve, even more so under Moyes, but at this point he's the most scrutinised player we've had for a while for just about no reason other than some preconceived notion.
Anyway, he should get away as there's a chunk of the fanbase that hates him based on nothing, but adores players who were in a similar positions and underperformed even worse, in a team that wasn't in several relegation fights in a row. He'll likely improve, even more so under Moyes, but at this point he's the most scrutinised player we've had for a while for just about no reason other than some preconceived notion.
Timbucktoo
Player Valuation: £20m
He reminds me of a wide midfielder that doesn`t help out his full back defensively, too easy to get past, which is very bad when he is the actual full back.
Could be a market for him in the summer, Thelwel gone to Rangers and Lampard at Coventry.
Either would be a good move for him and for his sake he needs it developmentally if he's going to have a decentish career.
Either would be a good move for him and for his sake he needs it developmentally if he's going to have a decentish career.
BirkenheadBlue
Player Valuation: £70m
If only either of them had signed him.
…a player who struggles to defend will do so regardless of the level, Thelwell will surely know how poor he is but we can but hope.
I think the best we can do with him would be to loan him out for a season and hope he does well that way.
If Moyes persists with him in the next few games, there may be hope for him as Moyss may think he can get to work on his defensive flaws over the summer.
If he's dropped and Young or Coleman come in against Fulham, I'd say that's him done.
We are getting toward stick of twist with him mate, he has two years to run on his deal this summer, so we shouldn't let him enter his final year so we may get 5 mill for him - if we loan him for a year it could be with an obligation. I don't think he's breaking the glass ceiling here with us - he's almost 24 - he isnt a young prospect anymore.
The lad himself needs to take a step back at Coventry or somewhere to take a step forward - if he's ever going to.
Its not going to happen for him here, so the only game in town is try and get a few bob back on him.
Marius57
Player Valuation: £60m
Half what we paid for him would be 5.5m and a PSR profit. So if that happens, it’s not bad.
Back On The Grass
Player Valuation: £25k
In the unlikely event of an offer coming in for him, we should take it regardless of the amount. A new RB or JOB shifting back there with a new CB has to happen, unfortunately he's not good enough, end of.
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
