...he said without evidence.
I'll admit that he didn't develop as I had hoped, but at 20 or so years old when he joined everton, nobody knew how good he could be, yet the attacks were almost immediate, and by people that were admittedly anti rangers. So, it was perfectly reasonable to defend a young lady against what seemed to be irrational attacks, and that is what they were.
Positional sense can be learned, and every appearance he made, I was looking for evidence of failures there, and there were some, but he was hardly the only one on an everton team largely under the cost during his time here.