6 + 2 Point Deductions

[Moderatelywarmwater]

That Masters response suggests so I reckon, if the appeal was successful there would be nowhere to hide.

He’s written this presumably knowing the outcome of the appeal.

I hope I’m wrong, that’s our biggest source of appeal out of the window otherwise

 

[DuncansPigeons]

He’s written this presumably knowing the outcome of the appeal.

I hope I’m wrong, that’s our biggest source of appeal out of the window otherwise

I reckon the club still have legal avenues after this if they think they’ve been treated unfairly. They’re banned from CAS specifically but they can sue the PL in multiple courts

 

[Goodisongang]

Can see which way it's heading, little things getting leaked to the press about everton not looking on getting a good result appeal wise, masters replying back being his usual helmet smarmy self before the verdict is out.

 

[EFC_FRANCIS]

We really got Lionel Hutz round for a photoshoot at goodison only to keep a ten point deduction

 

[Buckers]

I think we should be allowed to swear on this thread.

 

[Moderatelywarmwater]

if you don't like the club rules, rather than acquiesce, you fight them in court.

That has to be where we go when we get a disappointing result to our appeal

There is no recourse to the uk courts in the rules.

 

[Lord Byron]

I wouldn’t be surprised if DCMS and Andy Burnham actually know what was in the documents from an inside source but cannot declare it until they were officially released.

He told the DCMS committtee he had never said he wanted to kick the regulator into the long grass. If that was in the documents he is a dead man.

 

[Moderatelywarmwater]

I reckon the club still have legal avenues after this if they think they’ve been treated unfairly. They’re banned from CAS specifically but they can sue the PL in multiple courts

As far as I understand it, you’re not correct on this.

However, I still think we will get a deduction for mitigating circumstances and the like. 4 points off

 

[MikeH72]

We really got Lionel Hutz round for a photoshoot at goodison only to keep a ten point deduction

What are you on about?

 

[arch stanton]

There is no recourse to the uk courts in the rules.

that may be the case but if I lodge a tort with a court, that bypasses the rules of the club and refer to the laws of the land. I've mentioned it before, thats how the Bosman ruling came about.

 

[blaze]

That response will be used to bring in independent regulators, refusing to be fully transparent about the whole process on the grounds of being a private business means they have openly admitted why the current structure doesn't work.

 

[Tony’s Carp]

There is no recourse to the uk courts in the rules.

You can't just put "we can do what we like and you can't sue us" in a contract and make it so. The law of the land is paramount and you can't exclude it, even if the other party signs the contract. They wouldn't necessarily intervene on the actual merits of the tribunal but I'm pretty sure the courts could get involved if the process has been unjust.

 

[Moderatelywarmwater]

You can't just put "we can do what we like and you can't sue us" in a contract and make it so. The law of the land is paramount and you can't exclude it, even if the other party signs the contract. They wouldn't necessarily intervene on the actual merits of the tribunal but I'm pretty sure the courts could get involved if the process has been unjust.

That would be a very high threshold though wouldn’t it? For a process we agreed to. I just can’t see it would ever happen. Wouldn’t we get into serious trouble fir breaching PL rules???

 

[EFC_FRANCIS]

What are you on about?

We paraded that super silk round goodison on Saturday. Now the toffeeweb super ITKs are saying he's bottled it.

 

[Moderatelywarmwater]

that may be the case but if I lodge a tort with a court, that bypasses the rules of the club and refer to the laws of the land. I've mentioned it before, thats how the Bosman ruling came about.

That was unlawful under employment law. This is a points deduction for breaking sporting rules. Even if we see this as unjust it’s a huge huge hill to climb.