- Status
Ring master
Player Valuation: £90m
Its been tested and trailed with refs trained for 2/3 years ,no amount of fixs will sort it and any they come up with will add more problems to VAR,for me.
Agree there are elements such as the 0.01mm offside crap.
But it doesnt cause as much chaos in Europe than it does here.
Ring master
Player Valuation: £90m
In italy before it was used in the prem league,refs even after looking at screen were giving pens for utterly nothing it looked like, and going over months in spain loads moaned about it,not sure on both now
Blue 1
Player Valuation: £70m
Never wanted it, it is as bad as I feared it would be, for all the reasons I thought it would. I would happily see it binned tomorrow.
What's the point if you can't celebrate a goal for fear of it being chalked off? It sucks balls and it is killing the game for me.
What's the point if you can't celebrate a goal for fear of it being chalked off? It sucks balls and it is killing the game for me.
Why does that mean he was offside? He didn't move towards the ball to try and change the direction or make the keeper think the ball would change direction.
Timhowardsswearbox
Player Valuation: £5m
Well said, Scoobs.
efcfanwirral
Player Valuation: £25m
It's an absolute technicality - but he did change the natural movement of the ball, it would've hit him if he hadn't moved (technically "dummying" it) but also if he wasnt there it's a goal.
The bad part is that this is so polarising. No rule should have this sort of argument.
Basically, get up off your backside when you go down and that won't happen...and it wasnt a foul because the phase of play continued to a shot so advantage was technically played.
But this didn't make the keeper think the ball direction would change which is what the rule is about. So if the keeper can see the ball which he could at all times then the rule is about if the offside player makes the keeper think the ball will change direction to deceive him which doesn't happen. De Gea tries to get back from the deflection and can't get there.
Billysgingham.
Player Valuation: £40m
He moved his feet was he was then in play so interfering.
Players coming back from an offside position move out of the way of the ball all the time and it's not an offside.
Nowhere in rules of offside does it say moving out of the way makes you active. Only if you impede a player from playing the ball or block a goalkeepers line if sight.
But like I just said the rule states if the offside player moves to try and touch the ball to deceive the keeper in the direction of the ball then it's offside. He never did that at all.
Exactly or the movement makes the keeper think the ball will change direction as they try or pretend to touch it. That never happened.
Nope.
Billysgingham.
Player Valuation: £40m
Yep, and to back it up it was disallowed.
- Status
