I wrote in the Central midfield thread that I see Gomes + 1 other as rotation options as hes either great or not good ar all.
I think this is how we will all feel by season end with a view of us in 2 seasons time:
GK -- Pickford / Lossl / Virginia
RB -- ??? / Kenny
CB -- Mina / ??? / Keane / Gibson
LB -- Digne / ???
DM -- Gbamin / ???
CM -- Gomes / ??? / Davies
AM -- Iwobi / ???
RF -- Richarlison / ???
CF -- Kean / ??? / DCL
LF -- Bernard / ???
That shows were 9 players short if we look ahead two seasons...it also factors in Kenny doing well on loan for 2 seasons before coming back as back up + Gibson coming through.
I think we need 6 players signed in Jan + next summer and then 3 more in the following 12 months with a view (as Brands mentioned) of then 3 in/out of the squad each summer going forward.
Having said that, we do have players like Richarlison and Iwobi who can play multiple positions so we could probably do ok with
1 New Right back
1 New Centre back
1 New Left back
1 New Defensive midfielder / Central midfielder
1 New Attacking midfielder
5 players in the next two windows to give the squad depth on key positions.
We know that the urgent requirements were Doucoure (DM/CM) Zouma (CB) Zaha (probably filled by Iwobi) and a right footed left forward.
I expect us to be after those 3 in Jan with another 2 or 3 in the summer.
Not unrealistic imo.
You've stated that you find Silva to be reactive, however a reactive manager would have taken off Gomes and DCL.
Also highlighted that hes a stubborn manager but one of those would have kept Gylfi on and stuck with the same formation.
Instead, hes taken off Bernard / Gylfi / Richarlison and thrown in Iwobi / Kean (both short of match fitness) and Walcott (to utilise his pace).
Aside from your Davies option, what other players could he have introduced....who could turn the game?
I'll answer it....none. the players he wanted which he stated were a DM/CM (Doucoure) and a left footed wide player along with a CB (Zouma) were not signed.
The squad has limited depth.