It may just be a sign of bad things had become since the Martinez mid-table seasons, but I actually think that the atmosphere at Goodison this season has been much better, and certainly more positive, than any time in the last five years. I stubhubbed my season tickets for the Watford game as I had already been up (from London) to a midweek game for Newcastle last week and couldn’t really justify more time off work and more expense so close to Christmas. However, even during the Newcastle game there seemed to be more roars and passion in the stands than we saw throughout most of last season. There is a greater air of positivity and noticeably more singing this season from my vantage point at least. Bear in mind that we also haven’t played any of the bigger teams at Goodison so far this season. The atmosphere even against such luminaries as Brighton and Fulham was better than every game I saw last season aside from Lyon and the derby.
Yes the crowd is full of moaners and those yelling out abuse, but for the most part that tends to be directed at the referees and opposition, as it should be. I was listening to a podcast the other day with Howard Webb who singled out Goodison as a notoriously challenging place to be a referee as the fans are always on top of you and giving out abuse for any decision that goes against us. I think at times this can count against us, as the refs decide to be “strong” by not giving the decision the crowd howls for, even when it is justified.
I'm not saying the atmosphere is perfect and Goodison is the Bombonera or St Pauli, but I think that this season the atmosphere has definitely improved. Football in England has changed beyond recognition from the days of a terrace being full an hour early, being made up of very young, working class men all tanked up. Yes, you can point to Germany as an example of how to have both a safe environment, an excellent product and good value, but you'll be raging against reality to suggest that we can somehow all become like that again, if we ever even were. As a minor example, just think of the crackdown and hysteria over a couple of smoke bombs at away games. We live in too sanitised a country these days and there isn't the widespread, or establishment, desire to be like Germany (or nearly any other European league) or how we once were...