David Moyes' best signing

[Cork Evertonian]

Tim Cahill and Nigel Martyn for me.I think Marcus Bent was one of his more underrated signings.He was not a 20 plus goal a season.But he gave it his all and he was a very useful player for us in that season we came fourth.Moyes had his faults but he knew quality when he saw it.

 

[Huyton Layne]

I've voted Cahill but if Seamus captained us to a trophy he'd quickly leapfrog them all

 

[GETEM]

Cahill all round
Coleman in our current team
Jermaine Beckford underrated signing

 

[MACCA75]

Don't really get the shouts for Martyn tbh. Yeah was a good keeper for a year or two - but ahead of someone like Baines? No contest.

 

[Tennessee Blue Mike]

Cahill then Arteta for me.

 

[ilikecheese]

Anton Peterlin

 

[Abertonian]

Baines for me but a list of amazing signings and you could make a compelling argument for them all. Credit where it's due, Moyes managed to pull off some amazing signings given the budgets available.

 

[Woolverhampton_Blue]

For me it's a hard choice between Arteta, Cahill and Seamus.

Arteta was £2m, our best player, gave us the best years of his career, and then was sold for £10 million.

Cahill was £1.5m, a fantastic player who really 'got' Everton, and left on good terms for £1m.

Seamus cost 60k, has become one of the best RB in the league, is rightfully being touted as a potential captain, and if sold would command a significant fee.

Gone for Coleman just because of the outstanding value and potential to be an even better buy than he already is.

Honourable mentions for Pienaar, Jags, Baines and Pienaar. Got to give Moyes his dues, was incredible in the transfer market.

 

[LABlue2]

Voted Arteta

Reckon Lescott would be top 5

 

[fandjango]

straq

 

[Eggs]

...Cahill. What a value for money buy he was, loved his commitment and ability to influence the biggest of games.

 

[banno]

Arteta for me. Class player with a bit of snide

 

[evilwebby]

Francis Jeffers. Obvs.

 

[Ihaters]

Stones was pretty good for us, joined us, bought us a load of excitement in an era of disappointment then left for vast sums of money. Basically another Lescott.. Still Baines for me though.

 

[Timak]

I always said the danger of the post-Moyes era would be we'd end up another club that recruited brainlessly. And we did.