James McCarthy

[MACCA75]

Not sure what you are getting at tbh. I'll be surprised if he's at the club in February though.

 

[diggerdestroyer]

We'll see if he has it in him to fight for a future at Everton. Seems more likely to sulk until he's allowed to join the mighty Crystal Palace tbh.[/QUO

How did u come to tha conclusion? Did he sulk before?

 

[bicycleheader]

Not sure what you are getting at tbh. I'll be surprised if he's at the club in February though.

You are happily basing an opinion on nothing but news reports

I am helpfully advising against this practice

 

[windymiller]

You are happily basing an opinion on nothing but news reports

I am helpfully advising against this practice

As opposed to what? A personal chat with Jimmy? Maybe sharing a Mars bar with Pardew?

 

[bicycleheader]

How did you come to tha conclusion? Did he sulk before

he has used news reports. it's a common football fan past time.

read news report, or sometimes just headline.....form opinion. back that opinion up to the hilt on forums and down the pub

I fail to see the fun in it

 

[bicycleheader]

As opposed to what? A personal chat with Jimmy? Maybe sharing a Mars bar with Pardew?

As opposed to not taking things you don't know to be a fact and allowing them to form the large part of your opinion

Or in some cases using these unsubstantiated facts and using them to bolster a previously held conviction

 

[Sapie88]

Which poses the question "is Scottish players choosing to play for Ireland and act of secretarianism?"

Serious answers only please.

Surprised there isn't a mural of McCarthy and Bobby Sands on the Falls Rd to be honest.

 

[MACCA75]

he has used news reports. it's a common football fan past time.

read news report, or sometimes just headline.....form opinion. back that opinion up to the hilt on forums and down the pub

I fail to see the fun in it

There have been credible reports that he was happy to leave, even asked to leave. Somewhat backed up by Moshiri's 'statement'. Also by reading between the lines from Koeman's comments and his performances on a football pitch.

Amongst that, I had the temerity to form an opinion. Hope he isn't reading and I've made him cry, otherwise it's not a big deal really is it.

 

[bicycleheader]

There have been credible reports that he was happy to leave, even asked to leave. Somewhat backed up by Moshiri's 'statement'. Also by reading between the lines from Koeman's comments and his performances on a football pitch.

Amongst that, I had the temerity to form an opinion. Hope he isn't reading and I've made him cry, otherwise it's not a big deal really is it.

I read some reports too and decided I have no idea what McCarthy is actually like or what he does or doesn't want, so I couldn't really offer an opinion on that. I'm not very interested in whether he reads your poorly conceived opinions and cries.

 

[MACCA75]

I read some reports too and decided I have no idea what McCarthy is actually like or what he does or doesn't want, so I couldn't really offer an opinion on that. I'm not very interested in whether he reads your poorly conceived opinions and cries.

If you have no opinion, then perhaps this isn't the thread for you?
Start one on pedantry or fence sitting. Seems more up your street.

 

[mightymoyes]

Surprised there isn't a mural of McCarthy and Bobby Sands on the Falls Rd to be honest.

nope, ireland fans know hes gash too

 

[bicycleheader]

If you have no opinion, then perhaps this isn't the thread for you?
Start one on pedantry or fence sitting. Seems more up your street.

I have an opinion. It was on your recent postings. I've just been sharing them with you Mac.

My opinions on all other things McCarthy related or not, will be posted as and when I see fit.

thanks for your time

 

[MACCA75]

I have an opinion. It was on your recent postings. I've just been sharing them with you Mac.

My opinions on all other things McCarthy related or not, will be posted as and when I see fit.

thanks for your time

Brilliant. Been a pleasure.

 

[Bluerover]

Surprised there isn't a mural of McCarthy and Bobby Sands on the Falls Rd to be honest.

Grotesque post and, very unusually for me, reported.

 

[Sapie88]

Grotesque post and, very unusually for me, reported.

I know what you mean, McCarthy wouldn't know what a hunger strike is the chub.