Roberto Martinez Discussion - Including Live Poll (Poll Reset 1st May)

Martinez in or out?

  • In

  • Out

  • Getting splinters eating cheese on toast on the fence


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.


I can see kenwright wanting Moyes back but will Moshiri be talked into this? This will be Kenwright first choice. Let's hope Moyes doesn't want the job.
dont know mate stranger things have happened, and it a nice easy safe bet for them, he knows the club ,the players ect thought he went stale myself after a good start, but sad to admit it after wanting him gone he would do a better job than the current one.
 
dont know mate stranger things have happened, and it a nice easy safe bet for them, he knows the club ,the players ect thought he went stale myself after a good start, but sad to admit it after wanting him gone he would do a better job than the current one.

He might do a better job but it will be the same old stuff, safe football who outdated.
We need a top manager, pep, klopp, Conte, raniani, pochettiino. managers who are top tacticians. Moyes can not compete with those names, his job is now to rebuild teams maybe like villa. There are so many good managers in this league next season and we need our own.
 
He might do a better job but it will be the same old stuff, safe football who outdated.
We need a top manager, pep, klopp, Conte, raniani, pochettiino. managers who are top tacticians. Moyes can not compete with those names, his job is now to rebuild teams maybe like villa. There are so many good managers in this league next season and we need our own.
dont want him back myself, like i said wanted him gone. villa that place is a mad house, would be loony to take that job unless they get new owners
 

Understand your point, as of course the same critique "doesn't represent everybody" can be applied to absolutely any medium.

As an example, Goodison Park reflects it's customers, not all Evertonians.

To add, that's 28,000 active accounts (register/login/posts). More people will visit GOT in the next 10 minutes, than will be at Selhurst Park on Wednesday and inside a few hours, more will visit than will be at Goodison on Saturday.

Add to the 250,000 fans following GOT on social - we've never used our different comms to encourage votes on the manager. However, using our social CRM tool we can track all inbound messaging and from the last 100k interactions on social containing 'Martinez/Manager' there is a 92% negative sentiment score.

So that justifies running a poll to you? Fair enough, can't remember your Moyes Polls or Kenwright polls.

100k interactions, that's impressive and to be congratulated, do you think you can hide behind that?. How many of them are match going supporters? And really,who cares wtf Twitter thinks anyway?

Besides the deflection, you're still running an editorial. Daily Mail quoted today, Media sites, presuming this and Toffeeweb. Want Martinez out. Come here, there's only one impression you can get. You can't have your cake and eat it to. Moderators post on the forum, don't claim neutrality. And I agree with the posts by the way. You're a digital newspaper, like it or not. Hiding behind a wall of neutrality, suggesting that all we do is offer a forum for Evertonians to express their view. Calling BS on that. Run a poll, fine. Do it after there's nothing to play for. That's neutrality. Baiting when emotions are incensed, that's just pandering.

If you are really neutral, let people rant. Fume whatever and Lord knows there is plenty to bitch about. If you mention Goodison park and "customers" again. Sorry, I must be lost. Sure, cater to the "customers", run a poll. Some of us have been here for awhile and taken everything the club can throw at us. We'll still be here, after Kenwright, Martinez, or Toffeweb and Grand Old Team for that matter. Polls and "customers" are temporary. Supporters are permanent. You're a flagship for Evertonians around the globe, act like it.
 
Here's a thought.

People who don't think Martinez could take us down given the chance, how did he relegate Wigan? He dropped them down the league over a space of three years, which is exactly what is happening to us now. Teams don't normally just bomb out the league, they do it over a few years, for example the bottom three now are going yet 2 years ago they weren't. They were falling though so it's no surprises they have ended up the bottom three now.

This will happen to us. Considering we have one important player already making noises about leaving, the same situation will fall on us. Imagine taking this seasons form with the europa league after a cup win? Apparently it was the el fault we did poor last year, so it happening again would surely drop us completely?
 
Never will winning the fa cup come with such a price. Football is mad though ye just never know. I could never imagine wanting a manager out.even after winning the fa cup. I'll 100% agree he should get next season if he does but it doesn't mean I want it.

The club has already spoken to at least four potential replacements. It's just a matter of time now.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top