Naismith? Thoughts?

flibbyflob · October 21, 2012

He played better today than the guy he replaced. Can't ask any more than that.

MartSlinger · October 21, 2012

Ron Burgundy said:
Amazed people slating his performance today. Work really hard and was ok on the ball.

Osman, Neville, Jelavic and Coleman were terrible today

Dont agree with Jelavic. Had zero service today, what else can he do?

Toffe3m4n · October 21, 2012

Thought he did well when he came on actually, won the ball a few times it was pumped up to him.

hktoffee · October 21, 2012

Think he's alright today.

Ron Burgundy · October 21, 2012

MartSlinger said:
Dont agree with Jelavic. Had zero service today, what else can he do?

His first touch was poor today, was offside on a couple of occasions when he didn't need to be. Nothing wrong with his work rate but he was lacking in quality today.

Wasn't at the races at all.

Steve Wigan · October 21, 2012

Ron Burgundy said:
His first touch was poor today, was offside on a couple of occasions when he didn't need to be. Nothing wrong with his work rate but he was lacking in quality today.

Wasn't at the races at all.

Naismith was inadequate...again. His decision making is terrible, and although he runs around a lot, he seems to run the wrong way most of the time.He regularly commits DELIBERATE fouls...more than he should. He will never be a regular starter for anyone in the Prem, and I think he'll move on next summer and we'll make a nice profit.

Neiler · October 21, 2012

Just saw on Twitter - hes going to score in the derby, make of it what you will.

GrandOldTeam · October 21, 2012

There's nothing wrong with making an early judgement.

I'm not convinced.

But granted, the lad needs more time.

BlueLlama · October 21, 2012

He looks like he is made of cookie dough.

He was far from the worst today in the time he got but until he gets a run of games we can't judge properly

chicoazul · October 21, 2012

GrandOldTeam said:
There's nothing wrong with making an early judgement.

I'm not convinced.

But granted, the lad needs more time.

You hate him. I can tell when you don't like players and you absolutely loathe him already.

harry · October 21, 2012

i think he is a player that is good at finding space and bringing other players into the game. i dont think playing out wide suits his game. a bit like osman.

formerly manx toffee · October 21, 2012

Think I might prefer Naysmith

Christiffa25 · October 21, 2012

Thought he was as good as anyone else on the pitch today.

He needs a bit of a run of games tbf. Hoping he starts in the derby on the right if we can't appeal pienaar's 2nd yellow.

Beagers · October 21, 2012

Plays to orders a Moyes type player IMHO,did ok for us today.

tim cahill · October 21, 2012

Thought he should have played from the start today, and think he should start vs Liverpool with Pienaar out. If he isn't good enough to be a 2nd choice players then we really shouldn't have bothered.