Peter Reid for me. He was the piece of the jigsaw that made the difference.
windymiller
Player Valuation: £70m
I'm surprised Campbell isn't on the list given he was essentially free and saved us from relegation. Pretty big impact and excellent value. RIP Kev.
Drico
Player Valuation: £70m
No Seamus Coleman? The Yellow Pack of Irish footballers.
Was going to say the same. I can't stress enough the positive influence Peter Reid had on the team.
How’s Rodriguez made that list 
Impossible poll really but it is won and lost in midfield. Reid cost very little and was the man when we won titles. The bedrock of a brilliant team. Rooney was not with us long enough 1st time and was the best thing England ever produced, but that was elsewhere.
Because people in another thread seem to think the sun shines....I had forgotten he ever spent a season keeping the physios busy.How’s Rodriguez made that list
….Howard Kendall but he’s not on the list. Great player in arguably our best ever team, because of his association with the club he’s brought back as Manager and is the most successful in our history. Close thread.
No idea how Lineker makes it, only here one season and we won nowt, won the league the season before and then the season after he left. Some very odd ones on there, to be the best ‘value’ means having a valuable contribution to our history.
No idea how Lineker makes it, only here one season and we won nowt, won the league the season before and then the season after he left. Some very odd ones on there, to be the best ‘value’ means having a valuable contribution to our history.
Last edited:
Tony Hibbert
Without Hamez we wouldn’t have got Sassy ColumbianHow’s Rodriguez made that list
Unsure that is a positive
