ArtetaMagic
Player Valuation: £20m
We must sign him if we can
-
Turn On Christmas Radio
Bah humbug - to turn off the snow, visit your preferences and select a style that isn't Christmas.
Needs to score more goals to justify a high permanent signing fee
Zatara
Player Valuation: £100m
I could understand Moyes signing him. He seems to love him and has the experience Moyes values.
£15-20mil and it could make sense but its a fee that is never going to provide real value and the team would need to be setup to accomodate a player for the short term.
For me, i think he needs to REALLY wise up that hes playing for Everton and we want to see quick direct play rather than him slowing the play while players are waiting in the box.
Why?
We have Ndiaye who looks better on the left & the 'new Grealish' for the right.
The fee and wages could go on someone else who can play both wings and adds something different like crazy pace and goalscoring ability.
MaximusEvertonius
Player Valuation: £15m
This. I love Jack. He feels like an Evertonian. With him and Ndiaye on the wings is exciting. But the glaring difference between the two is that Ndiaye’s mindset propels him to try and score if there’s so much as an inch of space. Jack will hold up, pull out, or look to cross. I want us to keep him. But can you imagine if he played like Ndiaye?
Look at the list of players over 30 who play that wide attacking role for top 6 teams, it's generally non-existent and has been for the past decade. Salah would be the main exception but generally you don't want to be signing 30 year old's. Personally, I wouldn't have even loaned Grealish, I think it was basically a waste of £12 million.
Got to be honest, he was poor today.
davek
Player Valuation: £150m
No complaints up to now from me, but he looked like he was just there to mess about today.
davek
Player Valuation: £150m
...also, you see how KDH hit the line last week and then had very quick feet cutting back in again to get away from his marker to whip the ball across that forced the OG.
Grealish has great balance and can make space to clip a ball over, but his footwork turning back in again isn't going to put a defender out of the game like KDH can.
His first few games he was absolutely boss, difficult to keep that up week in, week out though. Agree with you on today, looked like he didn’t know what to do to get into the game.
davek
Player Valuation: £150m
He's possibly mentally and physically tired. This is a lot of games after not being involved last season at City.
Rehnman
Player Valuation: £950k
He’s had three really poor games on the trot. As a loan, he’s already more than justified himself - helping us transition from one way of playing to another and a future about the top rather than the bottom - but a permanent signing is another thing. We shouldn’t be offering a fee or long term contractual commitment to a player who’ll be about to turn 31. If we hold our nerve, we could get him for nothing tho - no one he’s going to want to join will pay big wages AND a big fee for him.
Too early to say if we should sign him imo.
But if Alcaraz or McNeil had thrown in some of his performances, they'd be crucified on here.
Phoning it in some games.
He's playing for a move, let's hope he can turn it on consistently.
Can't see there being queue of clubs ready to cough up £250k a week.
But if Alcaraz or McNeil had thrown in some of his performances, they'd be crucified on here.
Phoning it in some games.
He's playing for a move, let's hope he can turn it on consistently.
Can't see there being queue of clubs ready to cough up £250k a week.
Agree mate. He’s carrying the hope of fans and this team on his shoulders, that’s a lot mentally to take.
ArtetaMagic
Player Valuation: £20m
Who's the new Grealish? The one that goes to city for 100 million? What we need is a competent full back to help him out
WilliamBoo
Player Valuation: £950k
Today NDiaye did more in 5 minutes in the left than jack in the others 85
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
