VAR

[Cjplennon]

I think this is a tricky one. Seems the ref gave a penalty for a foul by Maguire which wasn't correct. So VAR look at it and think well maguire didnt do a foul sonits a clear and obvious error. If thye then analyse the shirt pull on its own, was that enough for a pen - i say they think it isnt enough and would be soft. So they say to the ref maguire didn't touch young do you want to take a look. He takes a look and says oh yes I see maguire did nothing so penalty overturned.
Whether they should.have shown him.thebshiry pull that he didn't see is a whole different question.
If the ref had spotted the shirt pull and said pen for the shirt pull to VAR I think they would not have intervened.

 

[Bedfordblue]

I think this is a tricky one. Seems the ref gave a penalty for a foul by Maguire which wasn't correct. So VAR look at it and think well maguire didnt do a foul sonits a clear and obvious error. If thye then analyse the shirt pull on its own, was that enough for a pen - i say they think it isnt enough and would be soft. So they say to the ref maguire didn't touch young do you want to take a look. He takes a look and says oh yes I see maguire did nothing so penalty overturned.
Whether they should.have shown him.thebshiry pull that he didn't see is a whole different question.
If the ref had spotted the shirt pull and said pen for the shirt pull to VAR I think they would not have intervened.

It’s all a load of horse .
They spend 15 mins looking at several ‘phases’ of play when Beto scored, once they start looking they’re obligated to see if the ref missed anything else in the run up.
It’s was a pen all day everyday and twice in any game the where fouled party wears red.

 

[Amw79]

I think this is a tricky one. Seems the ref gave a penalty for a foul by Maguire which wasn't correct. So VAR look at it and think well maguire didnt do a foul sonits a clear and obvious error. If thye then analyse the shirt pull on its own, was that enough for a pen - i say they think it isnt enough and would be soft. So they say to the ref maguire didn't touch young do you want to take a look. He takes a look and says oh yes I see maguire did nothing so penalty overturned.
Whether they should.have shown him.thebshiry pull that he didn't see is a whole different question.
If the ref had spotted the shirt pull and said pen for the shirt pull to VAR I think they would not have intervened.

And the answer is yes. Goals are getting ruled out or given every week, for stuff the ref didn’t see. For some reason they didn’t want to show him the full incident.

 

[TommyDavo]

I think this is a tricky one. Seems the ref gave a penalty for a foul by Maguire which wasn't correct. So VAR look at it and think well maguire didnt do a foul sonits a clear and obvious error. If thye then analyse the shirt pull on its own, was that enough for a pen - i say they think it isnt enough and would be soft. So they say to the ref maguire didn't touch young do you want to take a look. He takes a look and says oh yes I see maguire did nothing so penalty overturned.
Whether they should.have shown him.thebshiry pull that he didn't see is a whole different question.
If the ref had spotted the shirt pull and said pen for the shirt pull to VAR I think they would not have intervened.

Utter bull

 

[hoppy]

Keith Hackett has blasted the decision by Andy Madley to overturn his penalty award for Everton in stoppage time against Man United.

The former PGMOL chief and ex-FIFA official exclusively told Football Insider that referee Madley should have ignored VAR and stuck to his original decision to give the Toffees a spot-kick

 

[Cjplennon]

Utter bull

I agree. I'm just saying how in think it went not wheter the end result was right or wrong. I think it was a penalty. I dont think VAR is corrupt it's just being used in a terrible way and open to masses of human error and panic incorrect decisions

 

[blue to the bone]

I think this is a tricky one. Seems the ref gave a penalty for a foul by Maguire which wasn't correct. So VAR look at it and think well maguire didnt do a foul sonits a clear and obvious error. If thye then analyse the shirt pull on its own, was that enough for a pen - i say they think it isnt enough and would be soft. So they say to the ref maguire didn't touch young do you want to take a look. He takes a look and says oh yes I see maguire did nothing so penalty overturned.
Whether they should.have shown him.thebshiry pull that he didn't see is a whole different question.
If the ref had spotted the shirt pull and said pen for the shirt pull to VAR I think they would not have intervened.

Var should not have intervened at all.

 

[Street end man]

Get involved in a split and very close call. Then disrupt the game for 5 minutes dicussing it.
No way is that what VAR was supposed to be for.
Funny how they even tried to rule a goal out for us too today.
8 minutes of untransparent BS.....all aimed to assist a SKY sixer over us.
Corrupt.

 

[dannyboy]

Keep watching it back and it keeps getting worse every time. If that's United or Liverpool at home it's not even spoken about in terms of VAR. All season we've been told it's a high threshold for a decision to be overturned yet just look at that today.

 

[Bwana]

The whole United is built on stock market and debt. They need to be competitive, otherwise the stock will be like a Stuka. Diving with a scream. Unlike Stuka it won't be pulled up.

Too big to fail. The signs have been there already, "oh please government build us a new stadium" etc.

They are going down. Really down.

Hence this VAR.

 

[Street end man]

Keep watching it back and it keeps getting worse every time. If that's United or Liverpool at home it's not even spoken about in terms of VAR. All season we've been told it's a high threshold for a decision to be overturned yet just look at that today.

Gutting and just mind blowing the blatant unfairness of it all. If young dived then send him off with a second yellow.
The reasons for the overturn is sinister.

 

[Tommy Chong]

Utter bull

It's bigger than bull , mate. The way we got shafted today, it's more like:

And it equally stinks to high hell as well. I'm still seething because of it!

 

[arch stanton]

So in recent seasons against United VAR has ruled out 2 late winners, a goal by DCL which would've got us a replay in an FA Cup tie and then a clear penalty today but of course it doesn't favour the 'big' teams does it?

wasnt the one where siggurdson was on the floor in an offside position but pulled his legs in against united?

 

[mmmmsnouts]

VAR works in every country in the world except England. Wonder why that is.

Side note: That was a dive. Don’t blow 2-0 leads.

 

[Tommy Chong]

wasnt the one where siggurdson was on the floor in an offside position but pulled his legs in against united?

Yip, I was going to bring this one up.

Same fixture, a couple of seasons ago, VAR shafted us on that day as well.
He was NOT directly involved with the play, and his position did not hinder De Gea's view of the ball.