i would say 4-1-2-1-2
howard
neville jags distin baines
fellaini/rodwell
wide player 1 wide player 2
cahill
saha beckford
arteta coleman bilya osman and pienaar can duke it out for the wide positions, we have a full squad of capable players so lets get some competition for positions going. cahill is good enough with the ball at his feet to play centre attacking mid, and this would still allow him to get into the box and be a threat.
this would definitely be a more attacking formation, as arteta tracked back to defend today far more than cahill does generally, but if fellaini keeps playing the way he does at defensive mid and our cb's keep up the good work i think this formation would work well