VAR

[Lelouch]

I'm confused how it works, Does var not whisper to them that this is a penalty or this is a red the moment its occurred in case the ref didn't see it or not get a good view.

so like this
*penalty comitted
*ref didn't see it
*VAR checks it and confirms its a penalty
*ref awards a penalty
is this not how it's supposed to go?

 

[Tin-Tin]

There have been too many incidents that the VAR people have got so wrong recently its now becoming a joke. That Grealish one is criminal so imagine villa get relegated by 1 point defecit.

This is the tip of the iceberg

 

[Deulofeumygod]

Yarms’ elbow should get retrospective action but probably won’t.

 

[hallamblue]

There have been too many incidents that the VAR people have got so wrong recently its now becoming a joke. That Grealish one is criminal so imagine villa get relegated by 1 point defecit.

This is the tip of the iceberg

Funny how they didn't miss the Man City one. Just waiting for the first controversial goal in a match involving the rs

 

[daza_1973]

Funny how they didn't miss the Man City one. Just waiting for the first controversial goal in a match involving the rs

I think your in for a long wait.....
Seriously though when was the last time they even had a man sent off?

 

[brigadier]

Funny how they didn't miss the Man City one. Just waiting for the first controversial goal in a match involving the rs

They won't get one against them all season .

 

[NilSatisOptimum]

Voted no, as there is a need for complete transparency for all, when VAR decisions are used...

 

[DOMNOLAN]

I'm confused how it works, Does var not whisper to them that this is a penalty or this is a red the moment its occurred in case the ref didn't see it or not get a good view.

so like this
*penalty comitted
*ref didn't see it
*VAR checks it and confirms its a penalty
*ref awards a penalty
is this not how it's supposed to go?

Apparently the way it works is that when an incident occurs, the VAR people ask the ref what he saw. If what the ref saw happened, then they keep the decision. But this is a stupid way of doing it, because it just invites errors.

I can imagine it goes more like this:
-Leg breaking challenge occurs
-VAR man - "what did you see ref?"
- Ref - "well there was a bit of contact, but not enough for a pen"
- VAR man "There was indeed contact, the ref has seen it correctly"

Ludicrous way of doing it

 

[Lelouch]

Apparently the way it works is that when an incident occurs, the VAR people ask the ref what he saw. If what the ref saw happened, then they keep the decision. But this is a stupid way of doing it, because it just invites errors.

I can imagine it goes more like this:
-Leg breaking challenge occurs
-VAR man - "what did you see ref?"
- Ref - "well there was a bit of contact, but not enough for a pen"
- VAR man "There was indeed contact, the ref has seen it correctly"

Ludicrous way of doing it

Thanks.
wtf???? no wonder it's awful, The refs are already terrible as it is.

 

[kenada_blue]

There have been too many incidents that the VAR people have got so wrong recently its now becoming a joke. That Grealish one is criminal so imagine villa get relegated by 1 point defecit.

This is the tip of the iceberg

Haha.

So...there's still error but not as many errors as their should be.

So some games it'll work well, some won't.

Absolute joke.

 

[RFUS]

Think the arrogance of the refs in this league and the lack of will to overturn their pals' decisions is the real problem now.

Has the ref stopped to review footage on screen once this season?

 

[Cool_Blue]

How has Tielemans not got a red!

This is the clearest incident yet of how pointless it is. If that’s not a red, god knows what is. Imagine you’re the VAR ref, seeing that, and saying to yourself ‘that looks ok, even though he’s just broken Callum Wilson’s leg, hmmmm, just a yellow’. Absolutely joke.

 

[Ring master]

The Refs and the VAR are just making things up as they go along blaming each other,not knowing what to say etc or who is to blame,The Leicester one has just added to some Bizzare decisions so far,one of the most clear things you can see and yet they didnt even book him i dont think,it was an ankle breaker.
Wonder will you get that ref watch thing on sky backing the refs as usual saying the ref was right as they usually always do

 

[toffeejack]

Before any moans about VAR, football is the only sport to become worse after introducing technology, every other sport has thrived.

 

[ToffeeDan]

It’s like Bryan Hamilton Groundhog Day all over again...