The real question - who is the best full back?

[Khalekan]

Of course mate - Gary Naysmith and Tony Hibbert.

Darnitt....I forgot about dem two

 

[aloadofold......]

Chuckling at the fact that both our left backs scored goals against Manu this season..... Ridiculously good , and we were all worried about defenders performing with Berto coming in,hah!

 

[Brownie]

Apparently most days after training Tony will go up to one of them and say, "I think you were the best today", and pat a little sticker on their chest that says "I'm #1".

 

[Dom1878]

Coleman is the better defender, and better going forward - however Baines' delivery is far better...Coleman works on that and he is the best hands down.

 

[toffeejack]

baines, coleman's had a much better season though

 

[toffeejack]

Chuckling at the fact that both our left backs scored goals against Manu this season..... Ridiculously good , and we were all worried about defenders performing with Berto coming in,hah!

ironic seeing as moyes' main form of attack was from the left

 

[KopitesAreGobshi+es22]

Just love that we have so much quality at Left and Right back that we can't really decide who is better.

 

[Mogwai]

Both Boss.... But Baines is a playmaker which I don't think Coleman will develop into... Coleman makes his own plays though... Very lucky to have both...

 

[BlueLlama]

ironic seeing as moyes' main form of attack was from the left

Pretty much everything we did was pienaar and Baines down the left or hoof it to Fellaini for DMs lady couple of seasons. We are so much more balanced now so Seamus has more if a chance

 

[Portland Toffee]

And to think we have Oviedo Baby still to come back, what an amazing squad we are starting to build here. I love you Everton!

 

[Toffeelover]

Bit miffed here only given a coice of two, what about Ray Wilson, Sandy Brown, Mick Meagan, or even Alex Parker.

 

[Woolly Blue]

If you were going to judge on this season then I'd say Coleman's edged it, but Baines has consistently delivered over time. If Seamus keeps his form up for another two seasons then he'll probably end up being influential.

Overall, a score draw, so cheese on toast has it.

 

[PaddyG]

My brain just exploded.

So together, on toast.

 

[chrissyjack]

Its nice to know that if Baines AND Coleman are up front at the same time , the human dynamo McCarthy can cover both positions

 

[Verbal Kint]

I don't care tbh they are both top quality. Can't choose at the minute