The Good, The Bad and World Class

Status
Not open for further replies.

Goat

Player Valuation: £380m
1 GK Carlo Nash 5
2 DF Tony Hibbert 6
3 DF Leighton Baines 9.5
4 DF Joseph Yobo 8
5 DF Joleon Lescott 9.5
6 DF Phil Jagielka 9.5
9 FW Louis Saha 6
10 MF Mikel Arteta 10
11 FW Jô 7
12 GK Iain Turner 5
14 FW James Vaughan 7
17 MF Tim Cahill 10
18 MF Phil Neville 7
20 MF Steven Pienaar 9
21 MF Leon Osman 6
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 9
24 GK Tim Howard 7.5
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 9
26 MF Jack Rodwell 9
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz 4
28 FW Victor Anichebe 4
30 GK John Ruddy 4
32 MF Dan Gosling 7
35 FW Kieran Agard 6
37 FW Jose Baxter 7
38 MF James Wallace 7
— DF Séamus Coleman 7.5
— DF Shkodran Mustafi 7.5
— MF Anton Peterlin 6

Just something for fun, to see how we all rate our players, give everybody a mark out of 10 of how you rate them.

For the newer and younger players, give them the score that reflects how you think they will be.
 

1 GK Carlo Nash 5
2 DF Tony Hibbert 5
3 DF Leighton Baines 9.5
4 DF Joseph Yobo 8
5 DF Joleon Lescott 9.5
6 DF Phil Jagielka 9.5
9 FW Louis Saha 7
10 MF Mikel Arteta 10
11 FW Jô 7
12 GK Iain Turner 5
14 FW James Vaughan 6
17 MF Tim Cahill 10
18 MF Phil Neville 7
20 MF Steven Pienaar 9
21 MF Leon Osman 6
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 9
24 GK Tim Howard 7.5
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 9
26 MF Jack Rodwell 8
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz 4
28 FW Victor Anichebe 6
30 GK John Ruddy 4
32 MF Dan Gosling 7
35 FW Kieran Agard 6
37 FW Jose Baxter 6
38 MF James Wallace 5
— DF Séamus Coleman 6
— DF Shkodran Mustafi 7
— MF Anton Peterlin 5
 
1 GK Carlo Nash 5
2 DF Tony Hibbert 5
3 DF Leighton Baines 9+
4 DF Joseph Yobo 8
5 DF Joleon Lescott 9
6 DF Phil Jagielka 10
9 FW Louis Saha 7+
10 MF Mikel Arteta 9+
11 FW Jô 7+
12 GK Iain Turner 4-
14 FW James Vaughan 6+
17 MF Tim Cahill 9+
18 MF Phil Neville 6
20 MF Steven Pienaar 8+
21 MF Leon Osman 5+
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 9
24 GK Tim Howard 8
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 9-
26 MF Jack Rodwell 8
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz 4-
28 FW Victor Anichebe 5-
30 GK John Ruddy 4-
32 MF Dan Gosling 6
35 FW Kieran Agard 6+
37 FW Jose Baxter 6
38 MF James Wallace 6
— DF Séamus Coleman 6+
— DF Shkodran Mustafi 7+
— MF Anton Peterlin 6-
 

What an absolutely terrible thread. I'm sorry but this is absolutely abysmal and i'm absolutely crying at Louis Saha getting a 6.

Expect it from you though, so well in lad.
 
1 GK Carlo Nash 5
2 DF Tony Hibbert 6
3 DF Leighton Baines 9.5
4 DF Joseph Yobo 8.5
5 DF Joleon Lescott 9
6 DF Phil Jagielka 10
9 FW Louis Saha 7
10 MF Mikel Arteta 10
11 FW Jô 6.5
12 GK Iain Turner 5
14 FW James Vaughan 8
17 MF Tim Cahill 10
18 MF Phil Neville 8
20 MF Steven Pienaar 9
21 MF Leon Osman 6
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 9
24 GK Tim Howard 8
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 8
26 MF Jack Rodwell 9
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz 4
28 FW Victor Anichebe 4
30 GK John Ruddy 4
32 MF Dan Gosling 7
35 FW Kieran Agard n/a
37 FW Jose Baxter 6
38 MF James Wallace n/a
— DF Séamus Coleman n/a
— DF Shkodran Mustafi n/a
— MF Anton Peterlin n/a

All those with n/a I haven't seen enough of to justify giving them a rating
 
Last edited:
1 GK Carlo Nash NA
2 DF Tony Hibbert 7
3 DF Leighton Baines 8.5
4 DF Joseph Yobo 7.5
5 DF Joleon Lescott 9
6 DF Phil Jagielka 9.5
9 FW Louis Saha 7
10 MF Mikel Arteta 9.5
11 FW Jô 6
12 GK Iain Turner NA
14 FW James Vaughan 6
17 MF Tim Cahill 10
18 MF Phil Neville 7
20 MF Steven Pienaar 7.5
21 MF Leon Osman 6.5
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 9
24 GK Tim Howard 8.5
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 7.5
26 MF Jack Rodwell 8
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz NA
28 FW Victor Anichebe 5
30 GK John Ruddy NA
32 MF Dan Gosling 8
35 FW Kieran Agard NA
37 FW Jose Baxter NA
38 MF James Wallace NA
— DF Séamus Coleman NA
— DF Shkodran Mustafi NA
— MF Anton Peterlin NA

A lot of guys I have not seen play, or hardly seen play. Have you guys actually seen all 4 keepers play?

Edit: Of all the people rating Peterlin, has anyone actually seen him play?
 
Last edited:

The 2 young keepers have played in the 1st team, both in 1 match if I remember correctly when Turner got sent off for handling outside the area. And Nash has been around so i've seen him play a few times for Stockport etc.
 
1 GK Carlo Nash 3
2 DF Tony Hibbert 4
3 DF Leighton Baines 8
4 DF Joseph Yobo 6
5 DF Joleon Lescott 8
6 DF Phil Jagielka 9
9 FW Louis Saha 6
10 MF Mikel Arteta 9
11 FW Jô 6
12 GK Iain Turner 4
14 FW James Vaughan 7
17 MF Tim Cahill 8
18 MF Phil Neville 7
20 MF Steven Pienaar 8
21 MF Leon Osman 6
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 8
24 GK Tim Howard 7
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 7
26 MF Jack Rodwell 8
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz 3
28 FW Victor Anichebe 4
30 GK John Ruddy 3
32 MF Dan Gosling 6
35 FW Kieran Agard 6
37 FW Jose Baxter 6
38 MF James Wallace 6
— DF Séamus Coleman 6
— DF Shkodran Mustafi 6
— MF Anton Peterlin 6
 
1 GK Carlo Nash 5
2 DF Tony Hibbert 5
3 DF Leighton Baines 9
4 DF Joseph Yobo 8
5 DF Joleon Lescott 9
6 DF Phil Jagielka 9
9 FW Louis Saha 7
10 MF Mikel Arteta 9
11 FW Jô 8
12 GK Iain Turner 6
14 FW James Vaughan 7
17 MF Tim Cahill 10
18 MF Phil Neville 7
20 MF Steven Pienaar 9
21 MF Leon Osman 7
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 9
24 GK Tim Howard 6
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 9
26 MF Jack Rodwell 9
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz 4
28 FW Victor Anichebe 3
30 GK John Ruddy 5
32 MF Dan Gosling 7
35 FW Kieran Agard 6
37 FW Jose Baxter 7
38 MF James Wallace 7
— DF Séamus Coleman 5
— DF Shkodran Mustafi 6
— MF Anton Peterlin 5(y)
 
1 GK Carlo Nash 5
2 DF Tony Hibbert 6
3 DF Leighton Baines 8
4 DF Joseph Yobo 8,5
5 DF Joleon Lescott 8,5
6 DF Phil Jagielka 9
9 FW Louis Saha 7
10 MF Mikel Arteta 9,5
11 FW Jô 8,5
12 GK Iain Turner 5
14 FW James Vaughan 8,5
17 MF Tim Cahill 10+ (Sorry, hero status for me)
18 MF Phil Neville 7
20 MF Steven Pienaar 8,5
21 MF Leon Osman 7
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 9
24 GK Tim Howard 8
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 8,5
26 MF Jack Rodwell 9,5
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz 3
28 FW Victor Anichebe 4
30 GK John Ruddy 4
32 MF Dan Gosling 7
35 FW Kieran Agard 5
37 FW Jose Baxter 8,5
38 MF James Wallace 6
— DF Séamus Coleman 6
— DF Shkodran Mustafi 8
— MF Anton Peterlin 6
 
Fine! :lol:

1 GK Carlo Nash 6
2 DF Tony Hibbert 6
3 DF Leighton Baines 8
4 DF Joseph Yobo 7
5 DF Joleon Lescott 9
6 DF Phil Jagielka 9
9 FW Louis Saha 7
10 MF Mikel Arteta 10
11 FW Jô 8
12 GK Iain Turner 5
14 FW James Vaughan 8
17 MF Tim Cahill 9
18 MF Phil Neville 7
20 MF Steven Pienaar 9
21 MF Leon Osman 6
22 FW Yakubu Aiyegbeni 9
24 GK Tim Howard 8
25 MF Marouane Fellaini 6
26 MF Jack Rodwell 6
27 FW Lukas Jutkiewicz 4
28 FW Victor Anichebe 6
30 GK John Ruddy 4
32 MF Dan Gosling 8
35 FW Kieran Agard ? 6
37 FW Jose Baxter ? 7
38 MF James Wallace ? 7
— DF Séamus Coleman 6
— DF Shkodran Mustafi 8
— MF Anton Peterlin 6
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top