Baines a 2? What to hell were you watching FFS
Neville a 3? Do you hate him so much you are blinded to what he does?
I have a feeling you are a kopite or a plant of some sort
No i just watch the game
- Status
No i just watch the game
Respect opinions lads. Those who haven't here have been politely reminded.
bourneblue
Player Valuation: £10m
Youth on their side i wonder what the average age of each team was ,on the pitch after e.t. any stattos on here ?
Man Utds was 22.5
G@g
Player Valuation: £100k
Just having a go at sharing my view on players' performance. Love the result, but really didnt think the team did well.
Howard 6 (shaky at times, saved 2 weak pens)
Hibbert 5 (kept a defensive role throughout)
Baines 6 (fair number of overlaps, crosses disappoint tho)
Jags 6 (solid enuf, nearly gave away a pen, had better days)
Lescott 6 (solid and not caught out of position much)
Neville 6 (as others have noted, had an above-average day by his standards, he's done well enuf against a former team)
Osman 5 (full of running, great heart, capable of much more attacking)
Sub: Rodwell 7 (steady short passes, breaks up attacks, gave a good foul that killed a MU counter dead - brilliant that one)
Pienaar 7 (a lively threat, quickly closed down by opponents tho)
Fellaini 6 (put himself about well, still easily riled by opponents and ref, thank goodness for a wiser captain around him)
Cahill 6 (flashes of great shooting, otherwise a quiet day for him)
Saha 5 (happy to see him suit up, athletic display, but rarely threatens)
Sub:Vaughan 6 (troubled opponents with sheer presence and determination, wished Moyes will utilise him more)
P.S.: To be honest, Vidic was the outstanding individual in this game, his defending and leadership ensured MU stuck around for 120 mins.
Howard 6 (shaky at times, saved 2 weak pens)
Hibbert 5 (kept a defensive role throughout)
Baines 6 (fair number of overlaps, crosses disappoint tho)
Jags 6 (solid enuf, nearly gave away a pen, had better days)
Lescott 6 (solid and not caught out of position much)
Neville 6 (as others have noted, had an above-average day by his standards, he's done well enuf against a former team)
Osman 5 (full of running, great heart, capable of much more attacking)
Sub: Rodwell 7 (steady short passes, breaks up attacks, gave a good foul that killed a MU counter dead - brilliant that one)
Pienaar 7 (a lively threat, quickly closed down by opponents tho)
Fellaini 6 (put himself about well, still easily riled by opponents and ref, thank goodness for a wiser captain around him)
Cahill 6 (flashes of great shooting, otherwise a quiet day for him)
Saha 5 (happy to see him suit up, athletic display, but rarely threatens)
Sub:Vaughan 6 (troubled opponents with sheer presence and determination, wished Moyes will utilise him more)
P.S.: To be honest, Vidic was the outstanding individual in this game, his defending and leadership ensured MU stuck around for 120 mins.
Rook
Player Valuation: £80m
Howard 7 - the 1st penalty he saved was Berba's fault, the 2nd was a very good save
Jags and Lescott 8 - Jags covered up for Hibbo's deficiencies, Lescott did for Cahill's defensive deficiencies
Baines 5 - the announcer was right he has trouble beating people one-on-one.
Hibbo 4 had trouble w/ Utds pace. luckily Wemback can't finish
Neville 6 - played well, give him props for keeping Fellani calmed down just enough that he wasn't red carded
Fellaini 6 got screwed by Riley alot. The 1st 10 minutes he was great. Played hard, needs to watch his temper though.
Rodwell 7 - played very well against a bunch of players his age
Osman - 5
Cahill 6 - played well the 2nd half.
Saha 4 - not his fault. He needs service. Thanks to Vidic he didn't get a sniff at the net. Plus for large stretches we resorted to hoof ball which isn't his game.
Peanut 7 sent endless crosses
Vaughn 7 - I forgot how much I love him. He always has that deer in the headlights look on his face and just runs around in circles like a kid. If he could stay healthy at worst he's a super sub.
It wasn't our best match. We defended well. I think we got nervous when Sir Alex introduced the lineup. All of a sudded Utd were the underdogs.
Jags and Lescott 8 - Jags covered up for Hibbo's deficiencies, Lescott did for Cahill's defensive deficiencies
Baines 5 - the announcer was right he has trouble beating people one-on-one.
Hibbo 4 had trouble w/ Utds pace. luckily Wemback can't finish
Neville 6 - played well, give him props for keeping Fellani calmed down just enough that he wasn't red carded
Fellaini 6 got screwed by Riley alot. The 1st 10 minutes he was great. Played hard, needs to watch his temper though.
Rodwell 7 - played very well against a bunch of players his age
Osman - 5
Cahill 6 - played well the 2nd half.
Saha 4 - not his fault. He needs service. Thanks to Vidic he didn't get a sniff at the net. Plus for large stretches we resorted to hoof ball which isn't his game.
Peanut 7 sent endless crosses
Vaughn 7 - I forgot how much I love him. He always has that deer in the headlights look on his face and just runs around in circles like a kid. If he could stay healthy at worst he's a super sub.
It wasn't our best match. We defended well. I think we got nervous when Sir Alex introduced the lineup. All of a sudded Utd were the underdogs.
- Status
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
