Blue Heart
Player Valuation: £500k
The Chief Executive presumably.
The Chief Executive presumably.
Protest this afternoon outside PL HQ in London, 5.30pm.
Duncan Donuts
Player Valuation: £750k
So come on, come on, get down to PL HQ, wooooh.
GoldenToffee
Player Valuation: £50m
Apparently just two men and their dogs according to the Panda bummer.
I think the 20 clubs are members of the PL. They have influence as the revenue the members generate pay the bonuses for the board of the PL.
peteblue
Welcome back Wayne
The PL has an executive and a current CEO, Richard Masters……
Llyrap
Player Valuation: £2.5m
A further argument is that if we had to run Transfers past the Premier League how does it make sense for them to the say it was all on us. What was the purpose of us having to get their approval. Why did we have to run it past them if they were not prepared to refuse to register a player.
Further issues not really considered by the commission is that:
1. The Rules provided that there was a wide range of penalties available. Why did they consider that the entry point here was a harsh points deduction when the rules envisaged a wide range of penalties..
2. Secondly the Premier League is a group of companies who have entered into an agreement. That means that any breach of that agreement (ignoring the usual consequences of a breach of contract) should be determined by the companies themselves. The model put forward by the Premier League was not approved (6 points with 1 points per 5 million breach) and secondly all 20 companies agreed that the punishment for the failure by the big six for not acting with the utmost good faith was a fine. That is the only precedent that the Premier League has in terms of punishment and they ignored it.
3. Given that this is a contractual arrangement between 20 clubs the use of other examples in other countries or indeed the EFL as a guide is nonsense.
Leylo
Player Valuation: £35m
Vera leave ja
Vera ffs leave jack alone!
DanEFC92
Player Valuation: £90m
Arsenal boss Mikel Arteta on his former club Everton's 10-point deduction: "I feel very connected to the club and it is a very difficult moment as it puts the club in a difficult position. But they have found themselves in a difficult position before and managed to get themselves out.
"If there are qualities that describes that club it is the coverage, determination and the fight. They will fight against anything and I wish them the best."
"If there are qualities that describes that club it is the coverage, determination and the fight. They will fight against anything and I wish them the best."
WestStandLower
Player Valuation: £1.5m
Sorry but that’s not correct.
The head of the judicial committee of the PL is appointed by a vote at a general meeting of all PL shareholders ( the 20 clubs + the FA)
Any complaint raised by the PL is passed to the head of the judicial committee who then takes the matter forward
Member's of Independent Commissions are made up by members from the disciplinary panel who are appointed by the head of the judicial Committee through open competition or if a hearing requires a specific skill then again their place on a commission is determined by that same individual
I am far from sure that you would get total independence no matter which route you go down and would guess that’s the case in most matters but I do wonder if like a jury who reach a conclusion the sanction shouldn’t be a matter for the commission but a n other ( perhaps the shareholders) who at least would be more balanced
Davideeyore
Player Valuation: £20m
neil999
Player Valuation: £80m
He's looking well
johnjoeefc
Player Valuation: £20m
Got to think that we are going to get 4+ points back on appeal. I can't think of one pundit who has said this isn't harsh. We've had sky sports pundits, talksport pundits, match of the day pundits, fan group pundits including redmentv. Various other ex players.
The common consensus is that the punishment doesn't fit the crime and surely the weight of this will be strong in any appeal.
The common consensus is that the punishment doesn't fit the crime and surely the weight of this will be strong in any appeal.
