Player Ratings vs The Tiprats

Status
Not open for further replies.

Goat

Player Valuation: £380m
Howard - 7 - Excellent and I mean excellent save in the 1st half, didnt get a sniff of either goal.
Hibbert - 6 - Not bad, not great, few decent crosses, few crosses that made me cry, its Tony Hibbert folks.
Baines - 7 - I want whatever he eats for breakfast, tireless, never stopped, didnt really get his crossing going tho.
Yobo - 5 - Had a bit of a shocker for me, unlucky with the 1st goal, but slashed at a simple ball and cost us the 2nd.
Distin - 6 - Jury is out for me, average at best.
Billy - 6 - Should have scored, didnt really get into the game.
Pienaar - 9 - Sign him up and sign him up NOW.
Fellaini - 8 - Better today from Mophead, fought hard, won some nice headers and showed some nice touches.
Cahill - 7 - Tireless if not a little jaded showing, lots of heart.
Heitinga - 9 - I think I actually love him.
Jo - 8 - Decent showing, it cant be easy playing the lone striker, but I thought he did it well today.
 

Howard - 7
Hibbert - 6
Yobo - 5
Distin - 6
Baines - 6
Bilyaledinov - 7
Heitinga - 7
Fellaini - 8
Pienaar - 8
Cahill - 6
Jo - 6
 
Howard - 7 - one handed save was world class
Hibbert - 6 - decent links down the right with Pienaar
Yobo - 5 - poor showing
Distin - 6 - as Goat said, not really too impressed so far, jury's out.
Baines - 7 - 100% effort
Bilyaledinov - 6 - hasn't got the left side partnership with Baines going yet
Heitinga - 7 - Rock hard
Fellaini - 8 - good game, plays well against the shyte
Pienaar - 8 - we've missed him, need to sign him up asap.
Cahill - 7 - His heart's in it 100% but he needs a rest
Jo - 6 - does he understand the offside rule?
 

Howard - 7

Hibbert - 6
Yobo - 5
Distin - 7
Baines - 7

Pienaar - 8
Heitinga - 8
Fellaini - 8
Bilyaletdinov - 7

Cahill - 6

Jo - 7
 
Howard - 8 - Stunning save first half, other than that had nothing to do

Hibbert - 7 -
Thought he played well today, one of his better games
Yobo - 5 - I just don't recognise Joseph this year
Distin - 5 - Him and Yobo don't work as a pair at all
Baines - 8 - Our player of the season so far IMO, class again, how Bridge is ahead of him for the England team baffles me

Bilyaletdinov - 6 -
I really hope he comes good and adjusts to the English game, but he doesn't look like a £10m winger
Heitinga - 7 - Some lids gave him stick today but he is gonna be very influential for us in time
Fellaini - 8 - Magnificent today, just pipped by Pienaar for MOM
Pienaar - 9 - Superb, he's a different class
Cahill - 7 - All heart and fight, was decent today just needs a goal

Jo - 7/8
- His best game since his debut for us, done well today
 
I didn't think Leighton was all that fantastic today, he's better than he showed here.

Most of our players did well, Cahill still isn't being aggressive enough tho, I just don't know what's wrong with him, his attitude is weird.
 
I didn't think Leighton was all that fantastic today, he's better than he showed here.

Most of our players did well, Cahill still isn't being aggressive enough tho, I just don't know what's wrong with him, his attitude is weird.
He is not fit but has to play
 

I didn't think Leighton was all that fantastic today, he's better than he showed here.

Most of our players did well, Cahill still isn't being aggressive enough tho, I just don't know what's wrong with him, his attitude is weird.

I love Tim but he needs to spend less time with his face screwed up at the referee and more of that smashing through defenders bit.
 
Howard 7 - made a brilliant save, couldn't have done much more today
Hibbo 7 - was as you expect from him. Solid defensively.
Baines 7 - you know he can do better, but again he was solid
Yobo 6 - unlucky with the first, horror show for the second, but he made one or two good blocks
Distin 7 - not sure why people are bagging him. Their strikers barely had a sniff today
Heitinger 9 - was Gerrard on the pitch? Superb game from Heitinger.
Billy 6 - he had a good first half before fading in the 2nd. That miss will haunt him.
Pienaar 9 - along with Heitinger the best player on the pitch.
Fellaini 8 - super game from the big man. Him, Peanuts and Heitinger meant we bossed midfield.
Cahill 6 - a typically gutsy display from him but not at his best
Jo 8 - he played the lone striker role superbly, just unfortunate that none of his goals counted. His second was a great finish.
 
Howard - 7 - Excellent and I mean excellent save in the 1st half, didnt get a sniff of either goal.
Hibbert - 6 - Not bad, not great, few decent crosses, few crosses that made me cry, its Tony Hibbert folks.
Baines - 7 - I want whatever he eats for breakfast, tireless, never stopped, didnt really get his crossing going tho.
Yobo - 5 - Had a bit of a shocker for me, unlucky with the 1st goal, but slashed at a simple ball and cost us the 2nd.
Distin - 6 - Jury is out for me, average at best.
Billy - 6 - Should have scored, didnt really get into the game.
Pienaar - 9 - Sign him up and sign him up NOW.
Fellaini - 8 - Better today from Mophead, fought hard, won some nice headers and showed some nice touches.
Cahill - 7 - Tireless if not a little jaded showing, lots of heart.
Heitinga - 9 - I think I actually love him.
Jo - 8 - Decent showing, it cant be easy playing the lone striker, but I thought he did it well today.
Agree with the above but 9.5 for Heitinga what will he be like when he,s got the EPL pace(y)(y)(y)
 
I didn't think Leighton was all that fantastic today, he's better than he showed here.

Most of our players did well, Cahill still isn't being aggressive enough tho, I just don't know what's wrong with him, his attitude is weird.

He is not fit but has to play

I agree with you both really. I honestly think Tim is a walking wounded, you can see the amount of pain hes in. His body takes a battering during games and hes really struggling out there at times.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top