It's a serious suggestion (in that he really means it - no April Fools). Clearly it won't happen for all kinds of reasons. There are the obvious reasons (clubs, salaries, etc.). Additionally, he proposes "nationalising" 50 players, but as only 22 make the world cup squad that would leave 28 out in the cold, having sacrificed their club careers. What about players losing form between now and the WC? What about new and up and coming players, not selected in the 50, but in better form than them 2 years later?
What does worry me in terms of Pienaar, though, is that I can foresee them managing to get dispensation from FIFA to gather their WC squad a few months in advance of the tournament. If so, we could end up losing Pienaar for, say, the last 4 months of the 2009/2010 season - and that's a big problem, because that's the year we'll win the Premier League.
No smilies because I'm not kidding.