Moyes or Benitez ???

Who would you prefer now ?

  • Total voters
    280
Status
Not open for further replies.

Moyes had his time here, he done a great job in difficult circumstances.

I think we need a different approach.... let’s be honest Benitez is different than most of us expected
 

My comment would be Moyes’ focus on fitness training and how much the players hated preseason. Would happily see that back. I wish him well at West Ham, goes to show you can make a push for top4 without Newcastle budgets
 
banno said:
No that is a good attitude not wanting Moyes back. Why would we want him back after the stuff he came out with after spending 11 seasons with us, getting paid handsomely and leaving with applause still ringing in his ears.
Click to expand...
Great attitude wanting a fat Kopite mess at the helm
 
Benetiz or Moyes--Moyes had 11 seasons at EFC and Benetiz 11 games--impossible to compare. I wasnt in favour of his appointment but now he is in post we need to support and give him a chance. He inherited a poor squad full of deadwood (Holgate Davis Iwobi Gomez Tosun Delph) and no backup for RB or LB. Together with a disastrous injury list--At premiership level-the squad issimply not good enough--we need to give Benetiz a couple of windows to reshape the squad--thats if he is allowed to spend buy I suspect we will have to rely on the loan market which is not ideal for forward planning. I would sack Brands before Benetiz--his performance in the tranfer market has been appalling.
 
helpimonfire said:
I would prefer Duncan in charge. At least we get passion from him.

From the options above the Cheese looks the best.
Click to expand...
Duncans passion for the club will create a short term bounce only he simply hasnt got the tactical ability to drive the team forward and to be honest he has been part of the managerial problem--we need a complete clearout of the jobs for the boys brigade (unsworth ebrell ferguson)
 

People who criticise Moyes for the ‘knife to a gunfight’ mentality want to pay attention to what Benitez says after the inevitable Man City beating. Watch the way we sit back with 25% possession too.
He’s already crying about having no money to spend despite begging for the job.
 
GedMoore said:
Great attitude wanting a fat Kopite mess at the helm
Click to expand...
I mean we could have neither.

I know that everyone seems obsessed with there only being two managers on earth and all that.

Never go back anyway. If our greatest ever manager could not replicate success after returning then I highly doubt Moyes could (not that he had any proper success).
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top