Confirmed Signing Lucas Digne

Status
Not open for further replies.

Digne will definitley be first choice but Baines may still start as he will now be the best holding midfielder at the club if we don’t sort out that position in the next 2 weeks.

Baines > Schneiderlin
 

Time will be the judge of that

As it stands, I think we're getting the better player.

In terms of potential, I'd say Tierney is far better.

So while I agree that in an ideal world I would have preferred we push harder for Tierney, Digne isn't a bad alternative at all and I think we're getting the more rounded player as of this very moment.
 
Most people want Tierney because he's showing all the signs that he's going to be one of the best left backs in Europe, so signing him will mean we have a World Class left back in a couple of seasons that we can either keep and kick on with or sell for a huge fee

As Digne is older, the chances of him kicking on and making significant improvements now are less likely

Also, we can ease Tierney into the first team over the season and gradually ease Baines out, which will be a smoother process then essentially kicking Baines to the curb as soon as Digne signs

Tierney is just the better option, which isn't to say Digne is bad of course, but the point stands

We'll see, mate. He's a young kid playing well in a one way race, so difficult to judge how well he'd adapt. I just find it a bit strange. Digne is only 4 years older - not as if he's 30. Also has pedigree of playing for PSG, Roma and Barcelona.

If Brands/Silva truly thought he was the better option, they would have paid the extra £10m or so it would have taken to sign him.
 

Most people want Tierney because he's showing all the signs that he's going to be one of the best left backs in Europe, so signing him will mean we have a World Class left back in a couple of seasons that we can either keep and kick on with or sell for a huge fee

As Digne is older, the chances of him kicking on and making significant improvements now are less likely

Also, we can ease Tierney into the first team over the season and gradually ease Baines out, which will be a smoother process then essentially kicking Baines to the curb as soon as Digne signs

Tierney is just the better option, which isn't to say Digne is bad of course, but the point stands

nail on the head, looks like its going to be digne now though so gotta get behind him
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top