Gibson etc

Status
Not open for further replies.
X

xtradj

Player Valuation: £225k
Opinion?

I don't rate the guy at all. Gives the ball away far too often, rarely gets forward, just doesn't seem to do anything for me. Seems to make up the numbers.

If fellaini goes our midfield looks weak at most. Osman past his peak, pienaar not the player he once was, ageing. Not many other options mirales decent, Naismith useless. Think we need to target 2 players very least in midfield. Hopefully ross can come on this season
 

I assume you rate Gibson then

Does it not worry you that most of our players are past peak and need replacing sooner than later. A club like us that lacks cash will be in the real **** one day when everyone is thirty odd and we don't have cash to replace all at once
 

xtradj said:
Opinion?

I don't rate the guy at all. Gives the ball away far too often, rarely gets forward, just doesn't seem to do anything for me. Seems to make up the numbers.

If fellaini goes our midfield looks weak at most. Osman past his peak, pienaar not the player he once was, ageing. Not many other options mirales decent, Naismith useless. Think we need to target 2 players very least in midfield. Hopefully ross can come on this season
Click to expand...

Did you watch Everton at all last season?
 
Problem with Gibson as highlighted with his long-term recurring injury is that he can't be relied upon game to game.

I'ts imperative a top midfielder is brought in next to Fellaini. With Gibson / lundstram as backup-- osman (lightweight) barkey (gives the ball away) should be further up the pitch.
 

He gave away so many passes towards end of the season. Rarely got forward and didn't see much of him defensively either. There was a reason united let him go remember. If we want to compete with sides like that we need to be more ambitious than signing their rejects. He does a average job and i just don't see him as a player who can take us to the next level
 
xtradj said:
He gave away so many passes towards end of the season. Rarely got forward and didn't see much of him defensively either. There was a reason united let him go remember. If we want to compete with sides like that we need to be more ambitious than signing their rejects. He does a average job and i just don't see him as a player who can take us to the next level
Click to expand...

Nonsense. He's our most underrated player and the reason he left United was that he was injury prone. You don't last long there if can't keep fit.

He's an exceptional passer of the ball and tries to go forward as much as possible.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top