Fellaini v Moutinho

[keverton]

OK during the summer there was all the speculation surrounding moutinho coming to Goodison and a lot of people on here were thinking he would be the answer to all our problems. Then out of the blue in came fellaini. Knowing what we know now who would people prefer fellaini or moutiniho. Personally i think moutiniho never wanted to come and with all the injuries we have had fellaini has been able to play upfront a role moutinho would not have been able to fulfil also i dont believe he would have contributed as many goals although i do understand they are to completely differant styke of players. So who would you have knowing what we know now fellaini or moutiniho, Personally its fellaini for me

 

[Neiler]

OK during the summer there was all the speculation surrounding moutinho coming to Goodison and a lot of people on here were thinking he would be the answer to all our problems. Then out of the blue in came fellaini. Knowing what we know now who would people prefer fellaini or moutiniho. Personally i think moutiniho never wanted to come and with all the injuries we have had fellaini has been able to play upfront a role moutinho would not have been able to fulfil also i dont believe he would have contributed as many goals although i do understand they are to completely differant styke of players. So who would you have knowing what we know now fellaini or moutiniho, Personally its fellaini for me

Oh thats a tough one, i think i would probably have said Mounthino, but am no way unhappy with Fellaini, different type of player.

Personally i wouldnt mind getting Veloso before Mouthino.

 

[ToxtethBlue]

Completely different, not really a good comparison. I'd say Fellaini simply because he's a player that offers us something different.

Arteta could be compared to Moutinho, they play similar positions. We've found our Moutinho in Arteta, he's not needed anymore.

 

[Goat]

Different type of player, i think The Mout is more a Mikel player and since Mikel is now playing CM we dont need The Mout. So i would say Fellaini.

 

[keverton]

yeah it is a tough one i have gone for fellaini due to him being able to play upfront which in hindsight has been a massive boost, if we had got moutiniho instead of fellaini i would not be able to see where are threat would have come from during the recent injury crisis

 

[Goat]

Completely different, not really a good comparison. I'd say Fellaini simply because he's a player that offers us something different.

Arteta could be compared to Moutinho, they play similar positions. We've found our Moutinho in Arteta, he's not needed anymore.

Your a bad copycat you lid.

 

[Neiler]

Completely different, not really a good comparison. I'd say Fellaini simply because he's a player that offers us something different.

Arteta could be compared to Moutinho, they play similar positions. We've found our Moutinho in Arteta, he's not needed anymore.[/quote]


Ha ha i never thought id hear that sentence, would be a good squad player though!

 

[keverton]

i agree totally differanr types of players however both in the same price bracket and it would have been one or the other (if only both ) so just curious to see which one evertonians would choose

 

[Goat]

We have holes on our squad, Strikers clearly, but without injurys i would be fairly happy with what we have, we need a DM, as much as Pip is playing a blinder, we need some1 a little better, we need a winger. If we can get another pacy striker, a pacy winger and a rock DM we can win the World Cup.

 

[HalewoodBlue_ver.2.0]

Totally different type of player so i wouldnt choose either or

 

[ToxtethBlue]

Completely different, not really a good comparison. I'd say Fellaini simply because he's a player that offers us something different.

Arteta could be compared to Moutinho, they play similar positions. We've found our Moutinho in Arteta, he's not needed anymore.[/quote]


Ha ha i never thought id hear that sentence, would be a good squad player though!

Mikky's that good as I told you.

 

[Neiler]

Mikky's that good as I told you.

Hands up on that one mate i was on planet wrongness!

 

[Neiler]

Ih he better then Manny though?


*Kicks Cats and Pidgeons out of the way!

 

[HalewoodBlue_ver.2.0]

Ih he better then Manny though?


*Kicks Cats and Pidgeons out of the way!

Yes he doesnt feign injury!

 

[ToxtethBlue]

Ih he better then Manny though?


*Kicks Cats and Pidgeons out of the way!

At the moment yes.